JORDAN REID:
This week, the United Nations confirmed a fact about the October 7 Hamas attack on Israel that, frankly, we already knew: that sexual violence, including gang rape, sexualized torture and genital mutilation, it wasn’t an outlier event, it was part of the strategy. Notably, similar attacks occurred at multiple locations in a manner that suggested collusion and intent. The accounts I’ve read are too horrifying to repeat here. They will give you nightmares. They should.
You know, when this conflict began, I came out in full force as a supporter of Israel. I still support the Israeli people. I’m Jewish, and I can understand (to whatever extent a person who hasn’t lived through it can) that their retaliation isn’t about the October 7 attack in a vacuum. It’s about centuries of degradation, enslavement, displacement, centuries of fear.
But I read the stories coming out of Gaza, follow the journalists documenting the atrocities taking place there. In five months, more than 30,000 Palestinians killed, a vast number of them children. And while I can support the Israeli citizens, and do, I can’t support their leadership.
This week, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu described his plan for peace, basically [the] total demilitarization of Gaza, with Israel controlling all entry and exit points to the strip. The problem is, [as] I see it, destroying Gaza, militarizing the peace solution, it just creates additional incentives for radicalization. They’re trying to rid Gaza of Hamas, but in the process, aren’t they creating more potential followers? If I was living in a war zone and watching my civilian friends and family dying every day at the hands of Israeli troops, I can imagine all of a sudden finding Hamas’ position, as horrifying and inhumane as it is, far more appealing than the alternative.
Oh, and speaking of Hamas, their solution for ending the war?
GHAZI HAMAD:
Israel is a country that has no place on our land. We must remove that country…
JORDAN REID:
So, on the one hand, we have Israel, unwilling to make any concessions, operating under the goal of total elimination of Hamas. And on the other hand, we have the same. I have to say, it feels to me like it’s time for the U.S. to, well, A) to stop providing Israel with munitions, given how said munitions are being used, and B) just cut it out with the hemming and hawing. And though you know, Israel should really be more careful in their approach. This is not a situation where care is being demonstrated in any direction.
You know who I think may have come up with a solution? None other than Jon Stewart.
JON STEWART:
Starting now, no preconditions, no earned trust, no partners for peace. Israel stops bombing. Hamas releases the hostages. The Arab countries, who claim Palestine is their top priority, come in and form a demilitarized zone between Israel and a free Palestinian state.
JORDAN REID:
Imagine: collaboration with a shared goal of peace. It is beyond time for the global community to step in.
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
End of dialog window.
This is a modal window. This modal can be closed by pressing the Escape key or activating the close button.
This is a modal window. This modal can be closed by pressing the Escape key or activating the close button.
Commentary
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
‘Biased’: What Americans think of ‘mainstream media’
Feb 21 Dr. Frank Luntz‘Getting rid of them’: Americans discuss Trump and immigration
Feb 14 Dr. Frank Luntz‘Woke’: Why some Biden 2020 voters backed Trump in 2024
Feb 6 Dr. Frank Luntz‘A promise’: Cadets describe their journeys at West Point
Jan 10 Dr. Frank LuntzUS should stop providing arms to Israel
By Straight Arrow News
The atrocities of Hamas’ Oct. 7 attack on Israel have been well-documented, widely reported and verified by the United Nations. Since Oct. 7, however, Israeli offensives have killed around 1.5% of Gaza’s total population and displaced almost 90% of residents. With Israel facing accusations of genocide in the wake of these events, nations around the world have begun canceling trade deals, withdrawing ambassadors, and sanctioning the Jewish state.
Straight Arrow News contributor Jordan Reid argues that the United States should cease its arms shipments to Israel. She expresses solidarity and empathy with the people of Israel but asserts that the U.S. must nonetheless cease its military support of Netanyahu’s actions in Gaza and the West Bank.
You know, when this conflict began, I came out in full force as a supporter of Israel. I still support the Israeli people. I’m Jewish, and I can understand (to whatever extent a person who hasn’t lived through it can) that their retaliation isn’t about the October 7 attack in a vacuum. It’s about centuries of degradation, enslavement, displacement…centuries of fear.
But I read the stories coming out of Gaza, follow the journalists documenting the atrocities taking place there. In five months, more than 30,000 Palestinians killed, a vast number of them children. And while I can support the Israeli citizens, and do, I can’t support their leadership.
This week, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu described his plan for peace, basically the total demilitarization of Gaza, with Israel controlling all entry and exit points to the strip. The problem is, as I see it, destroying Gaza, militarizing the peace solution, it just creates additional incentives for radicalization. They’re trying to rid Gaza of Hamas, but in the process, aren’t they creating more potential followers?
If I was living in a war zone and watching my civilian friends and family dying every day at the hands of Israeli troops, I can imagine all of a sudden finding Hamas’ position, as horrifying and inhumane as it is, far more appealing than the alternative.
JORDAN REID:
This week, the United Nations confirmed a fact about the October 7 Hamas attack on Israel that, frankly, we already knew: that sexual violence, including gang rape, sexualized torture and genital mutilation, it wasn’t an outlier event, it was part of the strategy. Notably, similar attacks occurred at multiple locations in a manner that suggested collusion and intent. The accounts I’ve read are too horrifying to repeat here. They will give you nightmares. They should.
You know, when this conflict began, I came out in full force as a supporter of Israel. I still support the Israeli people. I’m Jewish, and I can understand (to whatever extent a person who hasn’t lived through it can) that their retaliation isn’t about the October 7 attack in a vacuum. It’s about centuries of degradation, enslavement, displacement, centuries of fear.
But I read the stories coming out of Gaza, follow the journalists documenting the atrocities taking place there. In five months, more than 30,000 Palestinians killed, a vast number of them children. And while I can support the Israeli citizens, and do, I can’t support their leadership.
This week, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu described his plan for peace, basically [the] total demilitarization of Gaza, with Israel controlling all entry and exit points to the strip. The problem is, [as] I see it, destroying Gaza, militarizing the peace solution, it just creates additional incentives for radicalization. They’re trying to rid Gaza of Hamas, but in the process, aren’t they creating more potential followers? If I was living in a war zone and watching my civilian friends and family dying every day at the hands of Israeli troops, I can imagine all of a sudden finding Hamas’ position, as horrifying and inhumane as it is, far more appealing than the alternative.
Oh, and speaking of Hamas, their solution for ending the war?
GHAZI HAMAD:
Israel is a country that has no place on our land. We must remove that country…
JORDAN REID:
So, on the one hand, we have Israel, unwilling to make any concessions, operating under the goal of total elimination of Hamas. And on the other hand, we have the same. I have to say, it feels to me like it’s time for the U.S. to, well, A) to stop providing Israel with munitions, given how said munitions are being used, and B) just cut it out with the hemming and hawing. And though you know, Israel should really be more careful in their approach. This is not a situation where care is being demonstrated in any direction.
You know who I think may have come up with a solution? None other than Jon Stewart.
JON STEWART:
Starting now, no preconditions, no earned trust, no partners for peace. Israel stops bombing. Hamas releases the hostages. The Arab countries, who claim Palestine is their top priority, come in and form a demilitarized zone between Israel and a free Palestinian state.
JORDAN REID:
Imagine: collaboration with a shared goal of peace. It is beyond time for the global community to step in.
Loss of USAID makes America and the world less safe
Trump’s ‘Gulf of America’ renaming is mere political spectacle
President Trump politicizes DC plane crash as Americans mourn
Project 2025 is Trumpism on steroids
Trump wastes no time marginalizing vulnerable communities
Underreported stories from each side
Vance is overwhelming favorite to be Trump’s successor in CPAC straw poll
25 sources | 16% from the left ReutersTrump administration reportedly shutting down federal EV chargers nationwide
21 sources | 10% from the right Getty ImagesLatest Stories
Government-imposed internet disruptions hit record high globally in 2024
Trump admin aims to protect child trafficking victims with deportation order
Starbucks slashes 1,100 corporate jobs, tells execs to be in office 3 days
2 Virginia Beach police officers killed by convicted felon: Officials
Pope has ‘good night’ as he battles double pneumonia and kidney failure
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trump, Bondi crack down on sanctuary for criminal migrants
Feb 21 Star ParkerHypocritical Elon Musk has all the power with zero accountability
Feb 21 Dr. Rashad RicheyTrump’s baby-faced bulldozers just getting started
Feb 20 Matthew ContinettiLoss of USAID makes America and the world less safe
Feb 20 Jordan Reid