The US Constitution gave Congress and Congress alone the power to levy federal taxes. Nevertheless, President elect Trump is promising to hike taxes unilaterally through executive action. The taxes Trump will raise are tariffs, which are the taxes that us, companies and consumers pay on goods made overseas. Under the Constitution, the tariff power belongs to Congress, but Congress, 100 years ago, decided to hand that power over to the executive. Blame the progressives of the early 20th century, they believed that smart, scientific, technocratic government could be better achieved if they gave more power to the bureaucracy and to the executive branch in general, they liked the idea of rule by experts. In this spirit, during the Great Depression, Congress passed and President Franklin Roosevelt signed the reciprocal Trade Agreements Act. It was an explicitly anti populist measure. Congressman always felt pressure to protect the manufacturers in their own district, but they also saw that protectionist trade policy tends to backfire. So rather than hold their ground against special interests or against the workers of their district, Congress handed control of tariffs over to the president. In the 1970s Congress passed more laws giving the President even more control over tariff rates. Now, Donald Trump is returning to the White House, and Trump believes that tariffs are a good tool for promoting US manufacturing and for exerting pressure on foreign governments. He has this fall, threatened to impose a 10% tariff on all imports from China and a 25% tariff on all imports from Canada and Mexico. While these tariffs would harm foreign companies, they are still taxes on the Americans who buy foreign goods. Notably, about half of the goods affected by tariffs are not final goods like computers or sneakers, but are raw materials that US manufacturers use to make other things, such as aluminum imported to make dishwashers in US factories, the president shouldn’t have the power to hike taxes on Americans without a vote in Congress. Thankfully, Congress can fix that. Senators Mike Lee and Rand Paul have both introduced bills that would slightly curb the President’s tariff powers by requiring congressional approval before the President can hike tariffs. Democrats spent the 2024 election attacking Trump’s tariff plans as middle class tax increases if they really mean it, Democrats could join forces with senators Lee and Paul to pass one of these bills and put on President Biden’s desk before Trump takes office. That would prevent tax increases on middle class Americans, and it would take power away from Donald Trump, but it would also require Congress to take on some accountability, and that’s the last thing Congress wants do.
Democrats, GOP must urgently cooperate to block Trump tariffs
By Straight Arrow News
Incoming U.S. President Donald Trump has pledged sweeping tariffs on U.S. imports from around the globe, including from U.S. neighbors and allies, but especially on Chinese goods. Trump contends that his tariffs, while initially shocking the U.S. and global economies, will ultimately be good for the long-term economic health of the United States. But economists disagree sharply with Trump’s assertions, and instead warn that the tariffs he is proposing would trigger a global economic crisis without accomplishing any of Trump’s stated goals.
Watch the above video as Straight Arrow News contributor Timothy Carney argues that Democrats must urgently work with Republican U.S. senators to draft legislation clarifying the levying of tariffs as a legislative power, not just an executive one, so that Trump has no way to unilaterally impose these tariffs through executive action when he returns to power.
Be the first to know when Timothy Carney publishes a new opinion every Thursday!
Download the Straight Arrow News app and follow Timothy to receive push notifications.
The following is an excerpt from the above video:
While these tariffs would harm foreign companies, they are still taxes on the Americans who buy foreign goods. Notably, about half of the goods affected by tariffs are not final goods like computers or sneakers, but are raw materials that U.S. manufacturers use to make other things, such as aluminum imported to make dishwashers in U.S. factories. The president shouldn’t have the power to hike taxes on Americans without a vote in Congress.
Thankfully, Congress can fix that. Senators Mike Lee, R-Utah, and Rand Paul, R-Ky., have both introduced bills that would slightly curb the president’s tariff powers by requiring congressional approval before the president can hike tariffs. Democrats spent the 2024 election attacking Trump’s tariff plans as middle-class tax increases. If they really mean it, Democrats could join forces with Senators Lee and Paul to pass one of these bills and put [it] on President Biden’s desk before Trump takes office. That would prevent tax increases on middle-class Americans, and it would take power away from Donald Trump, but it would also require Congress to take on some accountability, and that’s the last thing Congress wants do.
The US Constitution gave Congress and Congress alone the power to levy federal taxes. Nevertheless, President elect Trump is promising to hike taxes unilaterally through executive action. The taxes Trump will raise are tariffs, which are the taxes that us, companies and consumers pay on goods made overseas. Under the Constitution, the tariff power belongs to Congress, but Congress, 100 years ago, decided to hand that power over to the executive. Blame the progressives of the early 20th century, they believed that smart, scientific, technocratic government could be better achieved if they gave more power to the bureaucracy and to the executive branch in general, they liked the idea of rule by experts. In this spirit, during the Great Depression, Congress passed and President Franklin Roosevelt signed the reciprocal Trade Agreements Act. It was an explicitly anti populist measure. Congressman always felt pressure to protect the manufacturers in their own district, but they also saw that protectionist trade policy tends to backfire. So rather than hold their ground against special interests or against the workers of their district, Congress handed control of tariffs over to the president. In the 1970s Congress passed more laws giving the President even more control over tariff rates. Now, Donald Trump is returning to the White House, and Trump believes that tariffs are a good tool for promoting US manufacturing and for exerting pressure on foreign governments. He has this fall, threatened to impose a 10% tariff on all imports from China and a 25% tariff on all imports from Canada and Mexico. While these tariffs would harm foreign companies, they are still taxes on the Americans who buy foreign goods. Notably, about half of the goods affected by tariffs are not final goods like computers or sneakers, but are raw materials that US manufacturers use to make other things, such as aluminum imported to make dishwashers in US factories, the president shouldn’t have the power to hike taxes on Americans without a vote in Congress. Thankfully, Congress can fix that. Senators Mike Lee and Rand Paul have both introduced bills that would slightly curb the President’s tariff powers by requiring congressional approval before the President can hike tariffs. Democrats spent the 2024 election attacking Trump’s tariff plans as middle class tax increases if they really mean it, Democrats could join forces with senators Lee and Paul to pass one of these bills and put on President Biden’s desk before Trump takes office. That would prevent tax increases on middle class Americans, and it would take power away from Donald Trump, but it would also require Congress to take on some accountability, and that’s the last thing Congress wants do.
Why Democrats have soured on mail-in voting
Child car seat regulations might actually be impacting family planning
The government isn’t the answer to a stressed-out parenting culture
Real birth rate crisis lurks beneath the ‘childless cat ladies’ debate
Underreported stories from each side
Israel arrests Jerusalem man for spying on behalf of Iran
17 sources | 11% from the left Getty ImagesKFile: Pete Hegseth spread baseless conspiracy theories that January 6 attack was carried out by leftist groups
14 sources | 0% from the right AP ImagesLatest Stories
Congress unveils stopgap bill to avert shutdown
GrubHub agrees to $25m settlement for ‘deceptive’ practices
Disney pulls transgender storyline from upcoming Pixar series
RFK Jr.’s lawyer: NYT report over polio vaccine petition ‘categorically false’
'Dirty Dancing,' 'among 25 films named to National Film Registry
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
Give time, love and togetherness for the holidays
Wednesday Adrienne LawrenceDid Democrats learn anything from 2024 election?
Tuesday Ruben NavarretteGEC shutdown strikes a blow to government censorship
Tuesday Ben WeingartenElon Musk budget cuts will devastate GOP voters
Monday David Pakman