One of the strangest things to happen recently in American foreign policy was President Biden suggesting that the Israelis should not go into the city of Rafah. And the fact he said it would be a red line if they were to go in the city. Now, later, he kind of regrouped, withdrew that and said, well, the red line didn’t really mean a red line. But it was an odd comment, because if the goal of the Israelis, after the horrors of October the seventh and the people who were raped, killed, tortured, 40 babies who were beheaded, if the goal of the Israelis after that horrible day was to destroy Hamas, then you can’t create a sanctuary city. And yet, that’s what President Biden was suggesting, that somehow, as long as Hamas could be in Rafah, it could survive. The Israeli position has been very clear from day one, that this was finally an event so horrifying, that they could never again risk it happening. And they were going to methodically destroy the entire organization, all of the military forces of Hamas and all of their assets. That’s why they’ve been methodically going through what is turning out to be 300 miles of underground, basically the equivalent of the London subway system. That was, by the way, all concrete that was supposed to be going for humanitarian purposes, to build hospitals, churches, public housing, but instead was being stolen by Hamas to build underground tunnels. And the Israelis have been very methodically going after this.
There have been a substantial number of civilian casualties. And the reason is simple. Two things, one, anytime you have urban warfare, there are substantial civilian casualties. In fact, the American record in Afghanistan, Syria and Iraq is substantially worse than the Israelis. The Israelis have gone to great lengths with modern technology to minimize civilian casualties. But second, Hamas, as a policy, has deliberately put civilians at risk, deliberately hidden behind civilians, and deliberately wanted to increase the number of civilian casualties so they could then arouse worldwide opinion against Israel.
The fact is, violence could stop this evening. Hamas could surrender. They could give up the hostages, they could pledge to never again attack Israel. And yet, every time people talk about any kind of truce, the first principle of Hamas is it has to be temporary, because we reserve the right to resume the war. And remember, Hamas’ position is that not a single Jew will remain. In fact, they produce maps on which Israel does not exist. And it gives you some sense of the depth of their determination.
I thought it was very strange that the President took that position. I thought it was comical that he was overheard in a live mic right after the State of the Union telling Democratic Senator Bennett from Colorado that he was going to have a come to Jesus moment with Netanyahu, because Netanyahu is the leader of a Jewish state, [it] struck me, you might have [a] come to Moses meeting, or a come to Abraham meeting, probably it wouldn’t be as productive to have a come to Jesus meeting. And [it] just kind of showed you that Good Old Joe isn’t always quite with it. But this is a serious issue that involves life and death. And it’s going to continue, I think, another three or four months.
Commentary
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
‘A promise’: Cadets describe their journeys at West Point
Jan 10 Dr. Frank Luntz‘A disturbing pick’: Americans debate Musk, Trump’s cabinet picks
Jan 3 Dr. Frank Luntz‘Dysfunctional’: Americans share criticisms of Congress
Dec 27 Dr. Frank Luntz‘Instill optimism’: Americans on how future generations can succeed
Dec 20 Dr. Frank LuntzBiden should approve Israeli invasion of Rafah
By Straight Arrow News
Recent debates on the Israel-Hamas war have focused on a looming invasion of Rafah at the southern end of the Gaza Strip, where many Palestinian survivors have fled following the total destruction of northern Gaza. Advocates of the Rafah invasion contend that Hamas cannot be eliminated without an invasion and occupation of Rafah. Opponents warn that Israel is already embarking on a genocide and that an invasion of Rafah will only provide cover for additional atrocities against many more civilians.
Straight Arrow News contributor Newt Gingrich argues that the high casualties in Gaza are an unfortunate fact of modern urban warfare in dense population centers, not the result of deliberate genocide. Gingrich indicates that Israel should proceed with its planned operation in Rafah and prioritize the destruction of Hamas.
The Israeli position has been very clear from day one, that this was finally an event so horrifying that they could never again risk it happening. And they were going to methodically destroy the entire organization, all of the military forces of Hamas and all of their assets. That’s why they’ve been methodically going through what is turning out to be 300 miles of underground, basically the equivalent of the London subway system. That was, by the way, all concrete that was supposed to be going for humanitarian purposes, to build hospitals, churches, public housing, but instead was being stolen by Hamas to build underground tunnels. And the Israelis have been very methodically going after this.
There have been a substantial number of civilian casualties and the reason is simple. Two things, one, anytime you have urban warfare, there are substantial civilian casualties. In fact, the American record in Afghanistan, Syria and Iraq is substantially worse than the Israelis. The Israelis have gone to great lengths with modern technology to minimize civilian casualties. But second, Hamas, as a policy, has deliberately put civilians at risk, deliberately hidden behind civilians, and deliberately wanted to increase the number of civilian casualties so they could then arouse worldwide opinion against Israel.
The fact is, violence could stop this evening. Hamas could surrender. They could give up the hostages, they could pledge to never again attack Israel. And yet, every time people talk about any kind of truce, the first principle of Hamas is it has to be temporary, because we reserve the right to resume the war. And remember, Hamas’ position is that not a single Jew will remain. In fact, they produce maps on which Israel does not exist. And it gives you some sense of the depth of their determination.
One of the strangest things to happen recently in American foreign policy was President Biden suggesting that the Israelis should not go into the city of Rafah. And the fact he said it would be a red line if they were to go in the city. Now, later, he kind of regrouped, withdrew that and said, well, the red line didn’t really mean a red line. But it was an odd comment, because if the goal of the Israelis, after the horrors of October the seventh and the people who were raped, killed, tortured, 40 babies who were beheaded, if the goal of the Israelis after that horrible day was to destroy Hamas, then you can’t create a sanctuary city. And yet, that’s what President Biden was suggesting, that somehow, as long as Hamas could be in Rafah, it could survive. The Israeli position has been very clear from day one, that this was finally an event so horrifying, that they could never again risk it happening. And they were going to methodically destroy the entire organization, all of the military forces of Hamas and all of their assets. That’s why they’ve been methodically going through what is turning out to be 300 miles of underground, basically the equivalent of the London subway system. That was, by the way, all concrete that was supposed to be going for humanitarian purposes, to build hospitals, churches, public housing, but instead was being stolen by Hamas to build underground tunnels. And the Israelis have been very methodically going after this.
There have been a substantial number of civilian casualties. And the reason is simple. Two things, one, anytime you have urban warfare, there are substantial civilian casualties. In fact, the American record in Afghanistan, Syria and Iraq is substantially worse than the Israelis. The Israelis have gone to great lengths with modern technology to minimize civilian casualties. But second, Hamas, as a policy, has deliberately put civilians at risk, deliberately hidden behind civilians, and deliberately wanted to increase the number of civilian casualties so they could then arouse worldwide opinion against Israel.
The fact is, violence could stop this evening. Hamas could surrender. They could give up the hostages, they could pledge to never again attack Israel. And yet, every time people talk about any kind of truce, the first principle of Hamas is it has to be temporary, because we reserve the right to resume the war. And remember, Hamas’ position is that not a single Jew will remain. In fact, they produce maps on which Israel does not exist. And it gives you some sense of the depth of their determination.
I thought it was very strange that the President took that position. I thought it was comical that he was overheard in a live mic right after the State of the Union telling Democratic Senator Bennett from Colorado that he was going to have a come to Jesus moment with Netanyahu, because Netanyahu is the leader of a Jewish state, [it] struck me, you might have [a] come to Moses meeting, or a come to Abraham meeting, probably it wouldn’t be as productive to have a come to Jesus meeting. And [it] just kind of showed you that Good Old Joe isn’t always quite with it. But this is a serious issue that involves life and death. And it’s going to continue, I think, another three or four months.
We need one big budget reconciliation bill, not two
Looking forward to major shift in US government
The United States should stay out of Syria
Congress must invest in military, stay vigilant
Trump can nominate Patel, Hegseth, but will Senate confirm?
Underreported stories from each side
Hunter Biden artworks worth ‘millions of dollars’ destroyed in LA fires: NY Post
13 sources | 0% from the left ReutersCanadian industry groups call for help facing US tariffs
60 sources | 15% from the right Mert Alper Dervis/Anadolu Agency via Getty ImagesLatest Stories
Elasticsearch scheduled test post
Grand Central Station transformed as ‘Severance’ cast promotes season 2
Bias Comparison but no Bias Summaries
Bias Summaries but no Bias Comparison
Both Bias Summaries and Bias Comparison with two sides
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
We need one big budget reconciliation bill, not two
Jan 15 Newt GingrichRFK Jr. at Health Department a chance to tackle drug addiction crisis
Jan 15 Adrienne LawrenceIs Meta’s free speech overhaul a power play or real change?
Jan 14 Ben WeingartenAmerica is deeply divided. Here’s what you can do.
Jan 14 Ruben Navarrette