
Commentary
-
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
The Wall Street Journal editorial page stated that “Mr. Biden’s campaign promise that he’d appoint a black woman to the Supreme Court is unfortunate because it elevates skin color over qualifications.”
But, no pun intended, is it all really so black and white?
By looking at the one Black justice on the Supreme Court, Associate Justice Clarence Thomas, I believe we can sometimes find justification for taking race and gender into consideration when making a Supreme Court nomination.
Thomas is now the longest-serving sitting justice on the U.S. Supreme Court.
When he was nominated by President George H.W. Bush in 1991, there was never any question that Bush would nominate an African American to replace the legendary Thurgood Marshall.
However, as President Biden goes through the process of deciding which black female he will nominate, what most Americans will keep in mind is that race is not a reality with one dimension.
Despite what some might think, Black reality is as multifaceted and complex as is all of human reality.
And the views of Black Americans cover the full scope of the political spectrum.
Clarence Thomas has shown himself to be a brilliant conservative addition to the court.
Had not Bush felt it politically important to replace Marshall with an African American, our country would be the worse off for not having given this African American the opportunity to contribute immeasurably to our nation.
But what Biden thinks is a historical plus regarding race and gender matters with his opportunity to make this appointment, is to note the irony that the then-chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee through which Thomas’ nomination had to pass was our current president, Joe Biden.
The then-Sen. Biden presided over a confirmation hearing that he allowed to be transformed into a carnival of pornography, allowing Anita Hill to make shameful public accusations about Thomas that had no place in a Senate hearing.
In a recent documentary, Thomas spoke about what happened and how, under Joe Biden’s chairmanship of the Judiciary Committee, liberals sought to destroy him because he is a conservative: “People should just tell the truth: This is the wrong Black guy. He has to be destroyed. Just say it. Then now we will be honest with each other.”
In fact, the track record of liberals toward minority Americans who are not liberal is not pretty.
Janice Rogers Brown, a conservative/libertarian African American woman who served as a justice on the Supreme Court of California, was nominated by President George W. Bush to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. Senate Democrats blocked her nomination for two years until she was finally confirmed in 2005.
Miguel Estrada is a distinguished Honduran American attorney who arrived as an immigrant without being able to speak English and wound up graduating, magna cum laude, with a Juris Doctor degree from Harvard Law School. Democrats blocked Bush’s nomination of Estrada to the District of Columbia Circuit Court of Appeals because he is a conservative.
The point is our country has a complex history and cultural reality in addition to its ideals.
And among our ideals should be mutual human respect and decency.
So, let’s hope as our nation walks through the nomination of selecting our next justice for our Supreme Court, that President Biden will look beyond gender and race and actually take a deep look at merit:
And let’s pray that the progressive left doesn’t use the then senator Biden playbook that interjected racial stereotypes into the process so to only get black females of their progressive liking on the list.
-
Trump and Congress should advance education freedom
On March 11, President Trump announced more layoffs that will reduce the Department of Education to half of its former size. The layoffs are a major step towards eliminating the department altogether, a controversial goal. Proponents of this plan emphasize what they say is the need to invest more in private school vouchers instead of… -
Medicaid is a poverty trap that needs reform
Republicans cannot achieve their goal of cutting $2 trillion in federal spending over the next decade without cuts to Medicaid, according to the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO). Medicaid, the joint federal-state program that provides health coverage to more than 72 million low-income Americans, has been under attack by some Republicans who say it’s a… -
America is a republic with a legislative sausage factory
Republicans control both the House and the Senate, and while they largely agree on a shared set of funding and tax priorities for the federal budget, they have differing opinions about how to arrive at those goals. Specifically, they continue to debate whether they should try to pass everything altogether in one massive bill or… -
Trump, Bondi crack down on sanctuary for criminal migrants
Attorney General Pam Bondi announced that the Justice Department (DOJ) is suing Chicago, along with the states of Illinois and New York, as part of the Trump administration’s crackdown on undocumented immigrants and jurisdictions that restrict cooperation between federal immigration agents and local police. President Donald Trump has frequently criticized Chicago and Illinois for having… -
President Trump leads with bold action
The first few weeks of President Donald Trump’s second term have sparked a range of public controversies on everything from the Jan. 6 pardons to the abrupt shutting down of USAID and a constitutional crisis between the branches of government. But while Democrats raise alarms over these and other concerns, Republicans are celebrating the achievement…
Latest Opinions
-
Test post with no body copy
-
Getty Images
How does dyeing the Chicago River on St. Patrick’s Day impact fish?
-
Getty Images
Trapped Antarctic researchers reporting death threats from colleague
-
Getty Images
Democratic Party’s favorability ratings drop to record low: Poll
-
Getty Images
Israel accused of ‘genocidal acts’ against Palestinians in new UN report
Popular Opinions
-
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.