Commentary
-
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
The arrest of National Guardsman Jack Teixeira for leaking classified U.S. documents raised concerns that America’s intelligence apparatus is lagging behind other countries in human intelligence gathering (HUMINT). However, one area where the U.S. dominates the globe is in signals intelligence (SIGINT), which is the collection, monitoring, and deciphering of data.
Straight Arrow News contributor Peter Zeihan explains why the U.S. is so adept at this crucial form of intelligence collection.
Excerpted from Peter’s May 5 “Zeihan on Geopolitics” newsletter.
We’ve poked holes in the U.S. system and talked about Russian intelligence declining, so today, let’s look at what the U.S. dominates: signal intelligence (SIGINT). Next time you find yourself in the Netherlands, ask the local shopkeep how many languages he can speak…I bet it’s more than a few! On the flip side, if you head to the U.S., the answer is likely one…or two if you’re really lucky. That dichotomy summarizes America’s human intelligence (HUMINT) problem; a small recruiting pool requires lots of expensive training.
However, the U.S. does excel on the SIGINT side of things. This is the monitoring, deciphering, and sifting of mass amounts of data (texts, emails, etc.) and tracing it back to the source. Then the human side of things identifies and extracts the most important stuff. Since the U.S. is such a significant world player, it’s become extremely good at this. But do they do it alone? No!
The Americans partner with many allies, but four stand out: The UK, Australia, New Zealand, and Canada. With the U.S., they form The Five Eyes Alliance – a monitoring and sharing agreement that has given the U.S. a good grasp on global signal intelligence.
Encryption has made this process a bit harder, but processing power and AI have helped the U.S. lead the way in focused signal intelligence. This doesn’t mean that the Americans have abandoned HUMINT altogether; instead, SIGINT enhances and guides the strategy for the boots on the ground.
Hey everybody, Peter Zeihan here coming to you from just above Denver.
It’s almost May, which means it’s almost hiking season. Almost not yet. Anyway, I am going to talk a little bit about the other side of the intelligence question. So we poked a few holes in the American system, we’ve talked about the leaks, we’ve talked about how the Russians do theirs, and why they’re good at and why they’re maybe not as good as they used to be. But I’m gonna talk about how the United States does things. Now, the United States is a country that while it is firmly bilingual, the population as a whole is not particularly multilingual. So you know, you go to the Netherlands, and your random shopkeeper is going to speak like six languages fluently, and then you know, be able to come down to half a dozen more, most Americans are lucky like me if they can spell in English. And the truly fortunate among us are bilingual with Spanish. And that’s about it.
And that makes it a very small pool of people to draw from if you want to do large scale intelligence operations that have a human element to it. And so all of our intelligence programs include some very, very, very intensive language training, because not just not a lot of people come into the space with that, especially when you consider that one of the big pools for intelligent personnel are former military personnel, and if you are working for four or eight, you know, two, three, whatever tours, language competency in a foreign language isn’t necessarily all that common. Or maybe you have one. And since American foreign policy changes every few years based on who the rivalry of the moment happens to be, you know, we’re always having to recreate that language, that language competency, which means that when it comes to human, we’re not that great.
In addition, the United States is a very rich country, and convincing someone to go abroad and basically work in a danger zone for danger pay is a bit of a stretch. Whereas if you’re in a poorer country, or country that has a lot more geopolitical stress, right, in its immediate environment, it’s an easier sell to the population. So small pool, expensive pool, and that pool still requires extensive training. So the United States just doesn’t excel at human intelligence HUMINT. What we do excel at, however, is SIGINT, or signals intelligence. And that’s the idea that you intercept electronic signals, whether it’s in the form of a phone call, or an email, or text message or tweet, and you trace it back to its source and you monitor it, hopefully, without the other side realizing that you’re doing and you just kind of get the raw feed coming in. This is then processed with computers, which eliminates, you know, 99.9% of everything as noise. And then that last point 1% Approximately, goes through a human filter, where it’s sorted out to levels of importance,
Because the United States is the largest first world country and the largest economy in human history, and because electronic communications are now omnipresent. US has gotten really good at this. There was a program that the Europeans hated a few years ago, they called it Echelon where basically, the United States use its signals intelligence dragnet to cover all global communications. And while it was never as far reaching as the Europeans thought it was still pretty cool. Because all you need is a radio tower to collect the information. And if you throw in global cell towers plus global satellites, that has a lot of collection potential. Now, do we do it alone? The answer to that is a hard No, we cooperate with any number of allies, but there are four that are far more important than the others put together, the United Kingdom, Australia, New Zealand, and Canada. And collectively, these form what are called the Five Eyes, they cooperate on the gathering of intelligence, the analysis of what comes in, and then they share the findings among themselves. And that makes these four countries the tightest allies we have. Yes, we fight. That’s what family does. But it does mean that the United States has a grip a really good grip on signals intelligence the world over. Now, there have been some issues that have come and gone through the years that have made this more or less effective. The general obsession with encryption that started a few years ago certainly has made it more problematic. But AI and processing power has almost kept track with that. So the United States is able to once it identifies a person of interest, apply a lot of supercomputer time in order to crack whatever the encryption happens to be. That means that the dragnet covering all of humanity is pretty much non existent anymore. But focused signal intelligence is wildly effective, and it remains the United States number one source of intelligence information. That doesn’t mean we don’t do human, it doesn’t mean that human intelligence is not important to the United States. It’s critical, especially for any ongoing military operation with when it comes to locating suspects. But signals intelligence tells us where to look in the first place. And then those fewer those more rare human intelligence assets are deployed once we have a general idea of what sort of neighborhood we’re looking at. Okay, that’s it for me. Until next time,
-
What happens to China after Xi Jinping dies?
China is arguably the world’s second most powerful country, and its leader, General Secretary of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) Xi Jinping, plays a major role in many of its economic and military decisions. So, with no heir apparent, what happens to China when Xi dies? Watch the above video as Straight Arrow News contributor… -
Impact of Italy’s older, shrinking population
Births in Italy fell by 3.6% in 2023, reaching a record low and raising concerns for Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s efforts to address the country’s aging population. One senator from Meloni’s ruling party echoed Pope Francis’ call for Italians to have more children, stating that having children should be Italian women’s “main mission.” Watch the… -
Biden and Trump are both unfit to be president
According to a June pre-debate poll, a majority of Americans feel dissatisfied with having to choose between either Joe Biden or Donald Trump. The debate did little to address anxieties that voters have about these two candidates. Post-debate polls indicate that President Biden now trails former President Trump, yet many voters remain undecided. Watch the… -
Why the West can’t quit Russian oil
Oil and gas revenues have been Russia’s most important source of income, accounting for up to half of the total Russian budget over the last decade. Despite severe sanctions imposed by the West to curb Russian energy income following the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Moscow’s oil revenues don’t seem to have been significantly affected. Watch… -
Why Israel’s Supreme Court ended draft exemptions
On Tuesday, June 25, Israel’s Supreme Court unanimously struck down a military draft exemption privilege for members of its ultra-Orthodox Jewish community. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu relies on the support of two ultra-Orthodox parties to maintain power, both of which oppose the court ruling. The court held, in essence, that these military draft exemptions…
Popular Opinions
-
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
Latest Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum. We hope these different voices will help you reach your own conclusions.
The opinions published in this section are solely those of the contributors and do not reflect the views of Straight Arrow News.
Latest Commentary
We know it is important to hear from a diverse range of observers on the complex topics we face and believe our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions.
The commentaries published in this section are solely those of the contributors and do not reflect the views of Straight Arrow News.
Peter Zeihan
Geopolitical StrategistImpact of Italy’s older, shrinking population
Biden and Trump are both unfit to be president
Why the West can’t quit Russian oil
Dr. Frank Luntz
Pollster and Political Analyst‘Two bad choices’: Undecided voters before Biden-Trump debate
‘Money doesn’t go as far’: Americans discuss financial hardships
‘I am shocked’: Americans react to the Trump guilty verdict
Pete Ricketts
U.S. Senator for Nebraska