The future of Taiwan and advanced semiconductor chips

Sep 16, 2024

Peter Zeihan Geopolitical Strategist

By Straight Arrow News

The looming possibility of a Chinese military invasion of Taiwan has raised fears about a global disruption of advanced semiconductor chips, many of which are produced in and then exported from Taiwan. Some companies are attempting to catch up to Taiwan’s advanced chip production by scaling up production in the U.S. or elsewhere, but it is unclear whether those efforts would be enough to mitigate the international supply chain disruptions brought on by a Chinese invasion.

Watch the video above as Straight Arrow News contributor Peter Zeihan discusses the efforts other companies are making to catch up with Taiwan and questions the potential impact of these efforts if Taiwan were to face a Chinese military invasion.

Be the first to know when Peter Zeihan publishes a new commentary! Download the Straight Arrow News app and enable push notifications today!

The following is an edited excerpt from Peter’s Sept. 16 “Zeihan on Geopolitics” newsletter:

Taiwan has positioned itself as the dominant player in the semiconductor industry, but what would happen if a conflict with China broke out? Well, if semiconductor supply chain vulnerabilities are top of mind, then sure, this should be of concern (but you should also be worried about the thousands of companies and locations that are nowhere near Taiwan that make up the vast bulk of the supply chain).

Let’s move past those concerns for today and break down what Taiwan and companies like TSMC (Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company Limited) have planned for the future. We’ve seen Taiwan “cooperating” with the U.S. and Japan in recent years, but what’s going on?

The Trump administration demanded that TSMC build the best facility they possibly could in the United States, and it is… not happening. Taiwan’s efforts in the U.S. are little more than a kabuki effort to appease the U.S. and maintain its favor. In contrast, new fabs in Japan are moving along swimmingly, as the Japanese didn’t insist upon the cutting-edge technology that the U.S. wanted.

While the U.S. has companies like Intel trying to replicate (and surpass) the advanced semiconductor technology of Taiwan, progress is difficult and I wouldn’t expect anything to come of it soon in the next year or two. Taiwan understands perfectly the situation that it is in and is playing its cards very strategically.

Hey everybody. Peter Zion here coming to you from the southern rim of upper Lyle Canyon in Yosemite. Last time I was here, I hiked all the way up that Whew. That was exhausting. We’re just, we’re just gonna look at it from a distance this time. Anyway, today we’re gonna take another entry from the ask Peter forum. It’s about Taiwan and semiconductors, and the question is, why would Taiwan help relocate any facilities to the United States? Isn’t that kind of their guarantee that the United States will come defend them if there’s a conflict with China? The short version is not really two things going on here. Number one, never, ever, ever, ever, ever forget that the semiconductor supply chain involves over 9000 companies, half of which only produce one product for one end user. So Taiwan isn’t necessarily a strong point in the international supply chain for semiconductors, but there are literally 1000s of others. All these companies make products that ultimately end up in TSMC hands that they use to build on, operate the fabrication facilities, and, of course, fabricate the wafers and the semiconductors themselves. So you can have any number, literally 1000s of problems around the world that shut this whole thing down. And while Taiwan is certainly a node that is the single most important one is hardly the only one. The lasers come from California. The lenses come from Germany. The designs typically come from the United States. The silicon itself comes from North Carolina. It is diversified in that it’s everywhere, but it is not diversified in the fact that there are any backup plans. So if there was a war in Taiwan, I’m not suggesting the United States would or wouldn’t. States would or wouldn’t get involved. I’m saying it wouldn’t matter, because if we’re at that point, then the elements of the supply chain that are elsewhere in East Asia go offline. So intervening in that war doesn’t solve this particular problem. The second issue is that Taiwan’s not stupid. Taiwan is building fabrication facilities in the United States in order to please the United States. But as with everyone who cut a deal with Donald Trump, they kind of pulled the the wool over his eyes. They basically flattered it and said, yes, we’ll build a subconductor fabrication facility in Phoenix. It’ll build sub three nanometer chips, which, at the time the best in the world. What they neglected to say is they were going to provide blueprints, and so that facility has now been under construction for a few years. Now it’s making no progress. In fact, they’ve had to tear down many of the facilities and rebuild them from scratch, because the Taiwanese are flat out stalling. Similar things happened, a number of things that had to do with economic deals. For example, supposedly, TSMC was gonna build a facility Wisconsin that came Wisconsin that came to nothing. If the United States is going to establish an alternative supply to Taiwan, it obviously has to build the fabrication facilities. And the leading candidate for that right now is Intel. Intel is absorbing some new technology from the Dutch lithography company ASML, which is actually more advanced than what the Taiwanese are using, and they’re hoping, hoping, hoping to have that online in Columbus, Ohio within a couple of years. And if that works, we’re talking about Intel not simply being able to match the technological level of TSMC, but maybe leapfrogging it a little bit. Best case scenario, we are not going to see first wafers out of that facility for two years. I think four is probably a little bit more realistic, and those won’t be the one nanometer chips that Intel has started discussing. Although the new technology does look very promising, it’s just that these things take a long time to set up, years, and while Intel has made some great progress, their track record for doing things ahead of schedule is almost non existent. I have no doubt they’ll get there, but they’re not going to get there this year or next year or probably the year after. Okay, the alternative for TSMC is to also ingratiate themselves to other partners. After the United States, the single most important one is by far Japan, and they have started building fabrication facilities in Japan that are ahead of schedule, unlike the Phoenix facility, because Japan didn’t ask for the cutting edge stuff, they just asked for stuff that would help with their automotive industry. So you’re talking about chips that are horror quality than 10 nanometers, which is kind of the threshold for the really, really good stuff. So that facility doesn’t threaten TSMC business model. It allows them to solidify their strategic alliance with Japan, and Japan, of course, has the second most powerful navy in the world. So if there is a Taiwan war Japan will probably actually be there before the United States. So sound decision making from the Taiwanese on both deals with the United States, which they’re reneging on, and deals with the Japanese, which they are not the end. So.