Hey everybody, Peter Zeihan here coming to you from Huron peak in central Colorado, and today we’re going to talk about Romania. Romania is one of those middle powers that kind of has been dealt a bad hand, it’s got a good chunk of land in the lower Danube, and it’s bracketed by the Carpathian Mountains, but it’s not quite big enough to kind of stand up to the neighbors. So it’s got these two access, three access points, really, you’ve got the Vienna Gap to the northwest that allows access to the Northern European plain, got the Bessarabian Gap to the northeast, which allows access to what I call the Eurasian hoardlands. And then down south, you’ve got the Balkan Mountains that pinch off access to the Sea on Montemara region. Now, in the Northern Europe plains and the hoardlands and Montemara are all capable of supporting absolutely massive powers that have dominated history, as long as it’s been recorded. And Romania is kind of stuck in the middle, it has access to all three of them, but could never generate the sort of military force that is necessary to punch out beyond those gaps and do anything meaningful. In fact, because it’s proximate to all of these gaps, it is usually one of the first countries that gets conquered or amalgamated when one of those three mega-regions decides it wants to expand beyond their natural borders. And in that sort of environment, Romania faces a double bind.
Number one, whether it’s coming from the Northern European plane, or Montemara, or Eurasian hoardlands, it’s got to decide whether it’s going to fight or whether it’s going to accede, and if it chooses to accede, then it is not in charge of its own destiny anymore, and it usually ends up being a cog in somebody else’s empire.
The second problem is that Romania, while being the most populous of the countries in the squeeze zone in between, is certainly not the only one. And there are others that might be a little bit different, more defensible, and have a little bit richer geography, and Romania is in constant competition with all of them. So even if it can make its peace with its larger neighbors, it then has to make peace with its smaller neighbors. Some, like Bulgaria, usually gets along with pretty well, others like Serbia are touchy, but probably the biggest problem of all of them is Hungary. Two problems here.
Number one, Hungary has a little bit more defensive of a geography than Romania. So it has a little bit longer history in terms of being an independent power, especially since it is up against that Northern European plain gap. Bessarabia is a 50-mile gap. And it’s really hard for country the size of Romania to plug that. But the Vienna gap is only a couple miles wide, and most of that is the Danube River, make it fairly easy for even a small country like Hungary to hold the line. That means that Hungary and Romania are the two countries that tend to find themselves fighting more often than even the major powers that are in the lands beyond. If you want to go just back to the Cold War, the review of these delightful stories that came out at the end about how yes, we were in a Cold War of the West versus the Soviet empire, but within the Soviet Empire, the Hungarian and the Romanian intelligence services were duking it out behind the scenes, while we were technically on the same side.
Now looking forward, the Romanians have some decisions to make. They know that the European system is of limited duration. They know that it’s in demographic decline, and they know that there’s going to be a fight for the region once again, just like there has in every age of their history that has been recorded to this point. Until very recently, they were convinced that when the Russians came again, they’d have to cut a deal, that they wouldn’t have a choice. But the Russians are doing so poorly in Ukraine that the Romanians are starting to entertain the possibility that there might not even be a major power on the other side of the Bessarabian gap again. And that means that the other regional power that they would probably have to cut a deal with, Turkey, becomes a lot more digestible. Turkey is an up-and-coming power. The relations with Romanians going back centuries have been pretty good. They’ve been excellent since the Cold War, it may be a little cool, but certainly professional. And if the Romanians are entering a world where the Russians are no longer a strategic factor, but Turkey is, that that’s a partnership, that’s not vassadom. And that could potentially spell the greatest chapter in Romanian history to date.
There are plenty of caveats in that statement. Romania has among the world’s worst demographies, they have one of the top-10 countries in the world for using abortion as a birth control method, and they’re among the worst demographic structures in Europe. They’re gonna have to find a new economic model and they’re gonna have to figure out what happens post-E.U. and maybe even post N.A.T.O., these are all big questions, but the fact that they’ve got a rising partner in Turkey right next door, but not directly adjacent (Bulgaria’s in the way) that’s, that’s a pretty good setup. All right. That’s it. Take care.
Related
Commentary
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
What happens to China after Xi Jinping dies?
Jul 15 Peter ZeihanImpact of Italy’s older, shrinking population
Jul 8 Peter Zeihan‘On death’s door’: Undecided voters react to first debate
Jul 5 Dr. Frank LuntzBiden and Trump are both unfit to be president
Jul 5 Peter ZeihanRomania in a post-American world
By Straight Arrow News
Romania has traditionally relied upon regional partners to help guarantee its security against more powerful and hostile adversaries. Although typically pro-Russian, Romanians are now beginning to change their thinking in response to the Russia-Ukraine War, with Romanian generals warning that they might soon be fighting against Putin themselves.
Straight Arrow News contributor Peter Zeihan maps out Romanian history and outlines Romania’s best options in a post-U.S. and perhaps even post-EU world.
Below is an excerpt from Peter’s Feb. 2 “Zeihan on Geopolitics” newsletter:
Today’s discussion comes to you from Huron Peak. We’ll discuss one of the middle powers that’s been dealt a bad hand: Romania. At first glance, Romania’s geographic situation looks alright — a nice chunk of land near some water bracketed by the Carpathian Mountains —but zoom in, and you’ll find three very troubling access points.
These access points open up to areas that can support enormous powers, and Romania is just stuck in the middle. This means Romania is often first on the chopping block whenever those powers want to expand or branch out. So Romania is no stranger to being a cog in someone else’s empire.
Even if Romania could make peace with its extensive and mighty neighbors, a handful of smaller players are just as problematic… ahem, Hungary. So, the Romanians have been kept busy, to say the least.
Looking forward, Romania has some big decisions to make. They know Europe is in demographic decline, so there will be a power struggle for the region. They’ve seen Russia’s blunder in Ukraine, so there’s a chance they won’t have to roll over for Putin. So, a partnership with Turkey, one of the region’s emerging powers, could help carry Romania to the most significant chapter in its history.
That’s a bold statement, and yes, there are many caveats to it… but the potential to have a partner like Turkey that’s nearby (not directly adjacent) is a pretty good setup.
Access Peter’s other post-American world commentaries:
Hey everybody, Peter Zeihan here coming to you from Huron peak in central Colorado, and today we’re going to talk about Romania. Romania is one of those middle powers that kind of has been dealt a bad hand, it’s got a good chunk of land in the lower Danube, and it’s bracketed by the Carpathian Mountains, but it’s not quite big enough to kind of stand up to the neighbors. So it’s got these two access, three access points, really, you’ve got the Vienna Gap to the northwest that allows access to the Northern European plain, got the Bessarabian Gap to the northeast, which allows access to what I call the Eurasian hoardlands. And then down south, you’ve got the Balkan Mountains that pinch off access to the Sea on Montemara region. Now, in the Northern Europe plains and the hoardlands and Montemara are all capable of supporting absolutely massive powers that have dominated history, as long as it’s been recorded. And Romania is kind of stuck in the middle, it has access to all three of them, but could never generate the sort of military force that is necessary to punch out beyond those gaps and do anything meaningful. In fact, because it’s proximate to all of these gaps, it is usually one of the first countries that gets conquered or amalgamated when one of those three mega-regions decides it wants to expand beyond their natural borders. And in that sort of environment, Romania faces a double bind.
Number one, whether it’s coming from the Northern European plane, or Montemara, or Eurasian hoardlands, it’s got to decide whether it’s going to fight or whether it’s going to accede, and if it chooses to accede, then it is not in charge of its own destiny anymore, and it usually ends up being a cog in somebody else’s empire.
The second problem is that Romania, while being the most populous of the countries in the squeeze zone in between, is certainly not the only one. And there are others that might be a little bit different, more defensible, and have a little bit richer geography, and Romania is in constant competition with all of them. So even if it can make its peace with its larger neighbors, it then has to make peace with its smaller neighbors. Some, like Bulgaria, usually gets along with pretty well, others like Serbia are touchy, but probably the biggest problem of all of them is Hungary. Two problems here.
Number one, Hungary has a little bit more defensive of a geography than Romania. So it has a little bit longer history in terms of being an independent power, especially since it is up against that Northern European plain gap. Bessarabia is a 50-mile gap. And it’s really hard for country the size of Romania to plug that. But the Vienna gap is only a couple miles wide, and most of that is the Danube River, make it fairly easy for even a small country like Hungary to hold the line. That means that Hungary and Romania are the two countries that tend to find themselves fighting more often than even the major powers that are in the lands beyond. If you want to go just back to the Cold War, the review of these delightful stories that came out at the end about how yes, we were in a Cold War of the West versus the Soviet empire, but within the Soviet Empire, the Hungarian and the Romanian intelligence services were duking it out behind the scenes, while we were technically on the same side.
Now looking forward, the Romanians have some decisions to make. They know that the European system is of limited duration. They know that it’s in demographic decline, and they know that there’s going to be a fight for the region once again, just like there has in every age of their history that has been recorded to this point. Until very recently, they were convinced that when the Russians came again, they’d have to cut a deal, that they wouldn’t have a choice. But the Russians are doing so poorly in Ukraine that the Romanians are starting to entertain the possibility that there might not even be a major power on the other side of the Bessarabian gap again. And that means that the other regional power that they would probably have to cut a deal with, Turkey, becomes a lot more digestible. Turkey is an up-and-coming power. The relations with Romanians going back centuries have been pretty good. They’ve been excellent since the Cold War, it may be a little cool, but certainly professional. And if the Romanians are entering a world where the Russians are no longer a strategic factor, but Turkey is, that that’s a partnership, that’s not vassadom. And that could potentially spell the greatest chapter in Romanian history to date.
There are plenty of caveats in that statement. Romania has among the world’s worst demographies, they have one of the top-10 countries in the world for using abortion as a birth control method, and they’re among the worst demographic structures in Europe. They’re gonna have to find a new economic model and they’re gonna have to figure out what happens post-E.U. and maybe even post N.A.T.O., these are all big questions, but the fact that they’ve got a rising partner in Turkey right next door, but not directly adjacent (Bulgaria’s in the way) that’s, that’s a pretty good setup. All right. That’s it. Take care.
Related
What happens to China after Xi Jinping dies?
Impact of Italy’s older, shrinking population
Biden and Trump are both unfit to be president
Why the West can’t quit Russian oil
Why Israel’s Supreme Court ended draft exemptions
Underreported stories from each side
House Republicans request interview with White House physician
14 sources | 14% from the left AP ImagesIs college worth it? Poll finds only 36% of Americans have confidence in higher education
20 sources | 6% from the right Getty ImagesLatest Stories
Test Media Landscape in API
This is an election test post updated
Musk, Trump interview on X; Biden to speak at DNC; earthquake shakes LA
Judge overturns $4.7B NFL verdict
Americans paying off last summer's debt
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
Should Biden step aside or not?
Jul 8 David PakmanDebate disaster raises questions about Biden’s capacity to lead
Jul 5 Star ParkerAmericans deserve younger candidates, better ideas
Jul 5 Dr. Rashad RicheyDespite poor debate performance, Biden deserves our support
Jul 5 Jordan Reid