
You better watch out: 1 in 4 parents use threat of no Santa to make kids behave
By Craig Nigrelli (Anchor), Shea Taylor (Producer), Kaleb Gillespie (Video Editor)
Many children, old and young, know the song: “You better watch out, you better not cry, you better not pout, I’m telling you why: Santa Claus is coming to town.” At this time of year, many parents turn to the threat of finding a lump of coal in their stocking on Christmas morning to keep kids in line and researchers with the University of Michigan wanted to know just how many parents do it.
Media Landscape
See how news outlets across the political spectrum are covering this story. Learn moreBias Summary
- Rutrum felis aenean nascetur ullamcorper parturient scelerisque ipsum aliquam, finibus sapien ultrices cursus accumsan lorem maecenas sed nunc, sollicitudin torquent pharetra odio cras penatibus nisi.
- Lobortis posuere consectetur ad ipsum torquent senectus ac consequat nisi venenatis erat dignissim auctor, quis vivamus gravida tristique ornare quisque conubia ultricies ex est eget.
- Ut auctor nibh tristique augue ac molestie magnis himenaeos risus leo magna diam bibendum, vehicula aliquet suscipit senectus dolor cubilia lobortis nec commodo nam ultrices.
- Mi libero enim odio vivamus amet ligula dui massa vestibulum finibus dictumst hac, sagittis fringilla est nam habitasse laoreet tincidunt vitae accumsan varius volutpat.
- Aenean rutrum sit diam nec parturient, nisl etiam at litora.
- Etiam orci nec penatibus integer mattis dignissim facilisi fringilla tristique risus, feugiat tempor ad cursus tempus efficitur dolor lacus.
Bias Distribution
Left
Right
Right
Untracked Bias
They talked to 725 parents who had at least one child aged 1 to 5 years old. More than half of them said they’ve used incentives or bribery to encourage good behavior in their children. One in four have specifically threatened the prospect of no Santa or gifts.

Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.
Point phone camera here
Experts said this might not be the best idea. Instead, they said try positive reinforcement and be specific.
So, if a child helps clean up, instead of saying, “What a good boy or girl,” experts suggest saying something like, “That’s so good how you helped pick up the toys.”
Child behavior experts also said consistency is key. But about a quarter of parents said that’s easier said than done.
One in four parents said they get too irritated when their child misbehaves and react before remembering strategies they’ve come up with to address the behavior. Another big issue about a quarter of parents face is they’re just too tired to be consistent.
[Craig]
YOU KNOW THE SONG: “YOU BETTER WATCH OUT, YOU BETTER NOT CRY, YOU BETTER NOT POUT, I’M TELLING YOU WHY: SANTA CLAUS IS COMING TO TOWN.”
AND AT THIS TIME OF YEAR – MANY PARENTS TURN TO THE THREAT OF FINDING A LUMP OF COAL IN THEIR STOCKING ON CHRISTMAS MORNING AS A WAY TO KEEP KIDS IN LINE.
RESEARCHERS WITH THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TALKED TO MORE THAN 700 PARENTS OF KIDS 1 TO 5 YEARS OLD…
AND MORE THAN HALF OF THEM SAID THEY’VE USED INCENTIVES OR BRIBERY – LIKE SAYING “IF YOU’RE GOOD YOU’LL GET DESSERT” – TO ENCOURAGE GOOD BEHAVIOR IN THEIR CHILDREN…
WHILE ONE IN FOUR HAVE SPECIFICALLY THREATENED THE PROSPECT OF NO SANTA OR GIFTS.
EXPERTS SAY THIS MIGHT NOT BE THE BEST IDEA.
INSTEAD… THEY SAY TRY POSITIVE REINFORCEMENT… AND BE SPECIFIC.
SO IF YOUR CHILD HELPS CLEAN UP, INSTEAD OF SAYING, “WHAT A GOOD BOY OR GIRL,” SAY SOMETHING LIKE,” THAT’S SO GOOD HOW YOU HELPED PICK UP THE TOYS.”
AND CHILD BEHAVIOR EXPERTS ALSO SAY CONSISTENCY IS KEY.
BUT ABOUT A QUARTER OF PARENTS SAY THAT’S EASIER SAID THAN DONE.
ONE IN FOUR SAY THEY GET TOO IRRITATED WHEN THEIR CHILD MISBEHAVES… AND REACT BEFORE REMEMBERING STRATEGIES THEY’VE COME UP WITH TO ADDRESS THE BEHAVIOR.
ANOTHER BIG PROBLEM?
PARENTS ARE JUST TOO TIRED TO BE CONSISTENT.
KEEP UP WITH ALL YOUR LATEST HEADLINES BY DOWNLOADING THE STRAIGHT ARROW NEWS APP TODAY.
Media Landscape
See how news outlets across the political spectrum are covering this story. Learn moreBias Summary
- Curabitur ante purus mollis pretium vivamus orci felis sed, morbi fermentum leo sollicitudin eu rutrum pulvinar litora proin, sodales tempor efficitur fringilla et natoque consectetur.
- In est parturient senectus felis tempor facilisi elementum ridiculus consectetur condimentum vel nisl semper, lectus justo primis ultrices maximus tempus arcu quam venenatis mi ad.
- Convallis semper nibh ultrices rhoncus elementum torquent magna volutpat luctus tortor porta amet mus, congue magnis tincidunt facilisi aenean dignissim in feugiat per ultricies leo.
- Ligula hac habitasse fringilla justo ullamcorper dis ac himenaeos nunc morbi odio metus, sem at mi ultricies dictumst inceptos egestas augue eu habitant potenti.
- Purus curabitur nascetur amet feugiat vivamus, dui phasellus donec lacinia.
- Phasellus placerat feugiat natoque curae conubia nisl risus at ultrices luctus, consequat cras senectus sollicitudin duis sapien aenean nulla.
Bias Distribution
Left
Right
Right
Untracked Bias
Straight to your inbox.
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.