Skip to main content
Business

Why November’s 227,000 jobs added is not as impressive as it seems

Listen
Share

The U.S. jobs market beat expectations in November, adding 227,000 jobs after a bleak October report driven by hurricanes and strikes. At the same time, the unemployment rate ticked up to 4.2% from 4.1% in October, according to Labor Department data.

Payroll employment has averaged 186,000 jobs added per month over the last 12 months. While November’s numbers beat the 12-month average, Burning Glass Institute’s Director of Economic Research Guy Berger warns it may not be as impressive as it looks.

“I think this is a pretty ho-hum labor market,” Berger said. “We saw a big gain in jobs. It was expected because we had a bunch of striking workers at Boeing coming back to work, about 40,000 of them, and on top of that, we had a big hurricane last month.”

“You abstract from that noise of all those people coming back to work, and the monthly job gains are probably not very impressive right now,” he added. “The direction is definitely lukewarm.”

QR code for SAN app download

Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.

Point phone camera here

Employment in health care and hospitality drove much of the job gains, up 54,000 and 53,000 jobs for the month, respectively. Meanwhile, the retail trade lost 28,000 jobs in November.

The transportation equipment manufacturing sector added 32,000 jobs in November, reflecting workers returning from strike, the Bureau of Labor Statistics said.

BLS also revised up jobs data for the past two months. September was revised up by 32,000, from 223,000 jobs added to 255,000 jobs added. October was revised up by 24,000, from 12,000 jobs added to 36,000 jobs added.

BLS said the monthly revisions are a result of additional reports received from business and government agencies since the last published estimates, along with recalculating seasonal factors.

The Federal Reserve will use this latest jobs report to guide the committee’s next interest rate decision in mid-December. Right now, markets are heavily favoring a 25-basis-point cut.

“The unemployment rate is still moving upward a little bit, though less than they expected, and inflation has gone up more than they expected,” Berger said. “So I think on balance, it sort of says, well, we probably shouldn’t reduce interest rates as much.”

Berger said the Fed is in an uncomfortable spot right now because the data from its two mandates, price stability and maximum employment, are both a little less clear as to what direction they’re heading.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

[Simone]

The U.S. jobs market beat expectations in November, adding 227,000 jobs after a bleak October report driven by hurricanes and strikes. At the same time, the unemployment rate ticked up to 4.2% from 4.1% in October, according to Labor Department data.

Payroll employment has averaged 186,000 jobs added per month over the last year.  While November’s numbers beat the 12-month average, my guest says it’s not as impressive as it looks.

[GUY BERGER | DIRECTOR OF ECONOMIC RESEARCH, BURNING GLASS INSTITUTE]I think this is a pretty ho-hum labor market.

I’m Guy Berger. I’m Director of Economic Research at the Burning Glass Institute, and I spent a lot of time looking at the macro economy and labor markets. And I stare at this jobs report extra early every Friday.

We saw big gain in jobs. It was expected, because we had a, you know, we had a bunch of striking workers at Boeing coming back to work, about 40,000 of them. And on top of that, we had a big hurricane last month. And, you know, the two big hurricanes and Florida and the Carolina and Appalachia have dug their way out of them. And so those jobs, people that were temporarily not at work have come back. That’s not surprising. But like you abstract from that noise of all those people coming back to work, and the monthly job gains are probably not very impressive right now.

The transportation equipment manufacturing sector added 32,000 jobs in November. BLS says that reflects Boeing workers returning from strike. 

We saw the most job gains in health care and leisure and hospitality, together they added 107,000 jobs. Meanwhile, the retail trade lost 28,000 jobs on the month. 

The Federal Reserve will use this latest jobs report to guide their next interest rate decision in mid-December. Right now, markets are heavily favoring a 25-basis-point cut. The Fed started cutting rates in September when the decision to cut rates was more clear cut.

[GUY BERGER | DIRECTOR OF ECONOMIC RESEARCH, BURNING GLASS INSTITUTE]

The decision was easy, the job market was cooling and inflation was moderating. So like, It’s easy in that situation when you lower interest rates. Since then, what’s happened is the unemployment rates still moving upward a little bit, though less than they expected, and inflation has gone up more than they expected. So I think on balance, it sort of says, well, we probably shouldn’t reduce interest rates as much.

[Simone]

The situation today is a little less clear. On top of November’s jobs report, the Fed will also get another inflation reading before making its decision Dec. 18. For SAN, I’m SDR.