Voice of America reporters, unions sue over outlet closure


Full story

  • Journalists and unions filed a lawsuit against the Agency for Global Media, its CEO Victor Morales, and advisor Kari Lake. The lawsuit challenges the Trump administration’s closure of the agency, which runs Voice of America, as unconstitutional.
  • The suit claims the closure violated laws ensuring separation between taxpayer-funded journalism and the executive branch. The plaintiffs accuse the administration of targeting VOA for failing to align with its political agenda.
  • Lake defended the shutdown, citing alleged national security violations and misuse of taxpayer funds. The lawsuit seeks to reinstate over 900 full-time employees and contractors.

Full Story

Several journalists and four unions filed a federal lawsuit in the Southern District of New York on Friday, March 21, against the Agency for Global Media and their leaders over shutting down the agency. The suit names Kari Lake, the former Republican gubernatorial candidate and news anchor from Arizona who is President Donald Trump’s advisor to the agency, and also CEO Victor Morales.  

The suit claims the Trump administration’s shuttering of the agency, which runs Voice of America, is unconstitutional. 

“It halted VOA’s iconic journalism by ordering virtually the entire staff not to report to work, turning off the service, and locking the agency’s doors,” the complaint reads. “It has done so because it perceives VOA’s journalistic output to be inconsistent with this Administration’s favored viewpoint and political agenda.”

The lawsuit contends that the closure violates laws governing the agency, meant to separate journalists who work for the taxpayer-funded outlet and the executive branch.

Closure

Lake referred to VOA as “not salvageable” when announcing the agency’s closure on March 15. 

“Waste, fraud, and abuse run rampant in this agency and American taxpayers shouldn’t have to fund it,” Lake said.

She listed findings to reinforce the agency’s closure, including “massive national security violations, including spies and terrorist sympathizers and/or supporters infiltrating the agency,” and “a product that often parrots the talking-points of America’s adversaries.”

The suit seeks to restore the more than 900 full-time employees and hundreds more contractors to their positions. 

Tags: , , ,

Bias comparison

  • Media outlets on the left framed the Trump administration's actions regarding the Voice of America as "silencing" a crucial media outlet and a "moral failure," emphasizing the "unlawful" nature of the "shuttering" based on a federal lawsuit; this perspective amplified Archbishop Gudziak's "prophetic" stance against these actions, viewing them as more dangerous than external threats.
  • Media outlets in the center adopted a more neutral tone but included the term "giant rot" as a quote to describe the Agency for Global Media while also quoting Republicans who believe VOA is infected by left-wing propaganda.
  • Media outlets on the right while acknowledging the lawsuit and the term "unlawfully shutting down," de-emphasized the moral implications and the role of figures like Archbishop Gudziak.

Media landscape

Click on bars to see headlines

20 total sources

Key points from the Left

  • A federal lawsuit claims the Trump administration unlawfully shut down Voice of America, challenging the decision in U.S. District Court in New York.
  • Archbishop Borys Gudziak criticized the shutdown, stating that Trump silenced the service, which supports democracy and human rights.
  • Reporters Without Borders is involved in the lawsuit to protect Voice of America and press freedom, stating that a significant source of objective news is gone.
  • The lawsuit argues that the administration's actions are unprecedented, potentially ending many journalistic operations like Radio Free Asia and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Center

  • A lawsuit claims the Trump administration unlawfully shut down the Voice of America, asking a federal court to restore it, as it has provided news to countries without free press for decades.
  • The case was filed by Voice of America journalists, Reporters Without Borders, and unions against the U.S. Agency for Global Media and Kari Lake, who represents Trump.
  • The lawsuit argues the administration's actions have reduced crucial sources of objective news, leaving only censored state-sponsored media in many regions.
  • Kari Lake criticized Voice of America as a "giant rot" that needs to be rebuilt and described the agency as a "national security risk."

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Right

No summary available because of a lack of coverage.

Report an issue with this summary

Powered by Ground News™

Full story

  • Journalists and unions filed a lawsuit against the Agency for Global Media, its CEO Victor Morales, and advisor Kari Lake. The lawsuit challenges the Trump administration’s closure of the agency, which runs Voice of America, as unconstitutional.
  • The suit claims the closure violated laws ensuring separation between taxpayer-funded journalism and the executive branch. The plaintiffs accuse the administration of targeting VOA for failing to align with its political agenda.
  • Lake defended the shutdown, citing alleged national security violations and misuse of taxpayer funds. The lawsuit seeks to reinstate over 900 full-time employees and contractors.

Full Story

Several journalists and four unions filed a federal lawsuit in the Southern District of New York on Friday, March 21, against the Agency for Global Media and their leaders over shutting down the agency. The suit names Kari Lake, the former Republican gubernatorial candidate and news anchor from Arizona who is President Donald Trump’s advisor to the agency, and also CEO Victor Morales.  

The suit claims the Trump administration’s shuttering of the agency, which runs Voice of America, is unconstitutional. 

“It halted VOA’s iconic journalism by ordering virtually the entire staff not to report to work, turning off the service, and locking the agency’s doors,” the complaint reads. “It has done so because it perceives VOA’s journalistic output to be inconsistent with this Administration’s favored viewpoint and political agenda.”

The lawsuit contends that the closure violates laws governing the agency, meant to separate journalists who work for the taxpayer-funded outlet and the executive branch.

Closure

Lake referred to VOA as “not salvageable” when announcing the agency’s closure on March 15. 

“Waste, fraud, and abuse run rampant in this agency and American taxpayers shouldn’t have to fund it,” Lake said.

She listed findings to reinforce the agency’s closure, including “massive national security violations, including spies and terrorist sympathizers and/or supporters infiltrating the agency,” and “a product that often parrots the talking-points of America’s adversaries.”

The suit seeks to restore the more than 900 full-time employees and hundreds more contractors to their positions. 

Tags: , , ,

Bias comparison

  • Media outlets on the left framed the Trump administration's actions regarding the Voice of America as "silencing" a crucial media outlet and a "moral failure," emphasizing the "unlawful" nature of the "shuttering" based on a federal lawsuit; this perspective amplified Archbishop Gudziak's "prophetic" stance against these actions, viewing them as more dangerous than external threats.
  • Media outlets in the center adopted a more neutral tone but included the term "giant rot" as a quote to describe the Agency for Global Media while also quoting Republicans who believe VOA is infected by left-wing propaganda.
  • Media outlets on the right while acknowledging the lawsuit and the term "unlawfully shutting down," de-emphasized the moral implications and the role of figures like Archbishop Gudziak.

Media landscape

Click on bars to see headlines

20 total sources

Key points from the Left

  • A federal lawsuit claims the Trump administration unlawfully shut down Voice of America, challenging the decision in U.S. District Court in New York.
  • Archbishop Borys Gudziak criticized the shutdown, stating that Trump silenced the service, which supports democracy and human rights.
  • Reporters Without Borders is involved in the lawsuit to protect Voice of America and press freedom, stating that a significant source of objective news is gone.
  • The lawsuit argues that the administration's actions are unprecedented, potentially ending many journalistic operations like Radio Free Asia and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Center

  • A lawsuit claims the Trump administration unlawfully shut down the Voice of America, asking a federal court to restore it, as it has provided news to countries without free press for decades.
  • The case was filed by Voice of America journalists, Reporters Without Borders, and unions against the U.S. Agency for Global Media and Kari Lake, who represents Trump.
  • The lawsuit argues the administration's actions have reduced crucial sources of objective news, leaving only censored state-sponsored media in many regions.
  • Kari Lake criticized Voice of America as a "giant rot" that needs to be rebuilt and described the agency as a "national security risk."

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Right

No summary available because of a lack of coverage.

Report an issue with this summary

Powered by Ground News™