Skip to main content
Politics

Victory for migrant children held by Border Patrol in open-air detention sites

Media Landscape

See who else is reporting on this story and which side of the political spectrum they lean. To read other sources, click on the plus signs below. Learn more about this data
Left 18% Center 62% Right 21%
Bias Distribution Powered by Ground News

A federal judge in California ruled Wednesday, April 3, that Border Patrol officers near San Diego have illegally detained hundreds of immigrant youths in “open-air detention sites” without adequate food, water or shelter. The judge mandated their rapid transfer to “safe and sanitary” facilities, and the Department of Homeland Security is now facing a lawsuit.

The Southern Border Communities Coalition and its partners filed a lawsuit against the DHS’s Office for Civil Rights and Civil Liberties, claiming migrants endure “dire conditions” prior to processing at Border Patrol stations.

QR code for SAN app download

Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.

Point phone camera here

Judge Dolly Gee of the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California found that U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) has legal custody of minors at these sites and is responsible for their health and welfare.

The case spotlights seven locations near San Diego and Jacumba Hot Springs in southern California. The ruling highlighted waste disposal and sanitation issues described as “overflowing” and “unusable.”

“This means that the [open-air detention sites] not only have a foul smell, but also that trash is strewn about the [sites], and class members are forced to relieve themselves outdoors,” Gee said.

The court’s ruling requires CBP to cease holding minors at or directing them to open-air sites longer than needed for transport preparation to more suitable facilities.

CBP is reviewing the judge’s order and emphasized its commitment to swiftly moving vulnerable individuals and children to its facilities. However, officials have noted that their stations’ limited capacity hampers their ability to process all migrants at once, resulting in delays for some asylum-seekers.

The CBP’s juvenile coordinator must report in May on the number of minors detained in these conditions and the agency’s adherence to the court’s mandate.

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

[LAUREN TAYLOR]

A FEDERAL JUDGE IN CALIFORNIA RULED WEDNESDAY THAT BORDER PATROL OFFICERS NEAR SAN DIEGO HAVE ILLEGALLY DETAINED HUNDREDS OF IMMIGRANT YOUTHS IN “OPEN-AIR DETENTION SITES” WITHOUT PROPER FOOD, WATER, OR SHELTER SAYING THEY MUST BE QUICKLY PROCESSED INTO “SAFE AND SANITARY” FACILITIES. 

ACCORDING TO JUDGE DOLLY GEE— U.S. CUSTOMS AND BORDER PROTECTION LEGALLY HOLDS CUSTODY OVER MINORS AT THESE SITES AND IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THEIR HEALTH AND WELFARE. 

THE SOUTHERN BORDER COMMUNITIES COALITION AND ITS PARTNERS SUED THE DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY’S OFFICE OF CIVIL RIGHTS AND CIVIL LIBERTIES, ALLEGING MIGRANTS FACE “DIRE CONDITIONS” BEFORE BEING PROCESSED AT BORDER PATROL STATIONS.

THE CASE HIGHLIGHTS SEVEN LOCATIONS NEAR SAN DIEGO AND JACUMBA HOT SPRINGS IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA, WHERE THE RULING POINTS OUT ISSUES WITH WASTE DISPOSAL AND SANITATION, OFTEN LABELED AS “OVERFLOWING” AND “UNUSABLE.”


JUDGE DOLLY GEE
U.S. DISTRICT COURT | CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

“This means that the [open-air detention sites] not only have a foul smell, but also that trash is strewn about the [sites], and Class Members are forced to relieve themselves outdoors.”

[LAUREN TAYLOR]

THE COURT’S DECISION MANDATES CBP END HOLDING MINORS IN OR DIRECTING THEM TO OPEN-AIR SITES FOR LONGER THAN NECESSARY FOR TRANSPORT PREPARATION TO MORE APPROPRIATE FACILITIES.

CBP IS REVIEWING THE JUDGE’S ORDER AND HAS REITERATED ITS DEDICATION TO QUICKLY TRANSPORTING VULNERABLE INDIVIDUALS AND CHILDREN TO ITS FACILITIES. HOWEVER – OFFICIALS HAVE STRESSED THAT LIMITED CAPACITY AT THEIR STATIONS PREVENTS THEM FROM PROCESSING ALL MIGRANTS SIMULTANEOUSLY, CAUSING SOME ASYLUM-SEEKERS TO WAIT FOR SPACE TO BECOME AVAILABLE.

THE CBP JUVENILE COORDINATOR IS REQUIRED TO SUBMIT A REPORT NEXT MONTH DETAILING THE NUMBER OF MINORS DETAINED UNDER THESE CONDITIONS AND HOW THE AGENCY IS COMPLYING WITH THE COURT’S ORDER.