Top US retailers in toxic ‘Hall of Shame’ ahead of holidays
By Craig Nigrelli (Anchor), Shea Taylor (Producer), Bast Bramhall (Video Editor)
The holiday shopping season is upon us, and whether you’re looking for the perfect gift or ingredients for a delicious holiday meal, one health group is warning that you might want to be careful where you shop. The nonprofit Toxic-Free Future, which specializes in environmental health research and advocacy, released it latest Retailer Report Card on the use of toxic chemicals and some of the most popular names are featured in its “Hall of Shame.”
Media Landscape
See who else is reporting on this story and which side of the political spectrum they lean. To read other sources, click on the plus signs below. Learn more about this dataBias Distribution
Left
Toxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KIFIToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KVIAToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KCRA 3Toxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WCVBToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WLWTToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WMURToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WLKYToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WESHToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WDSUToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KETVToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WYFFToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WTAEToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KCCIToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KMBCToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WISNToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WBAL-TVToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WPTZToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WMTWToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WVTMToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WAPTToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KOATToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WPBFToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WGALToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WXIIToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KSBWToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WJCLToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KHBSToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KESQToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KEYTToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KMIZToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KIONRight
Right
For the report, Toxic-Free Future looked at the top 50 retailers in the United States and Canada and graded them on a scale of A to F, like a school report card.
Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.
Point phone camera here
The group looked at four different factors to determine a retailer’s grade:
- Corporate commitment, which is whether a company has adopted safer policies to avoid using chemicals and plastics of high concern.
- Transparency on whether companies are asking suppliers what ingredients they use in products and packaging.
- Whether retailers are working to “ban the bad,” like dangerous chemicals and harmful plastics.
- Whether the company is working to find safer solutions to these harmful chemicals and plastics.
Of the top 50 largest retailers, 17 scored a failing grade and only four got an A.
The retailers that ranked lowest on the list were ones that owned restaurants and dollar store chains like Five Below, Family Dollar and Dollar Tree. The retailers that received A grades were Apple, Sephora, Target and Walmart.
Target and Walmart, which also owns popular bulk chain Sam’s Club, were the only grocery retailers to get such a high grade.
Publix and Trader Joe’s received an F, Aldi got a D+, Costco and Kroger both received a C-, and Whole Foods scored a B.
Amazon and Best Buy received Cs and Starbucks got a D.
Get up to speed on the stories leading the day every weekday morning. Sign up for the newsletter today!
Learn more about our emails. Unsubscribe anytime.
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.
Find the complete report and a breakdown of how each retailer’s score was calculated here.
[Craig Nigrelli]
THE HOLIDAY SHOPPING SEASON IS UPON US AND WHETHER YOU’RE LOOKING FOR THE PERFECT GIFT OR INGREDIENTS FOR A DELICIOUS HOLIDAY MEAL – ONE HEALTH GROUP IS WARNING YOU MIGHT WANT TO BE CAREFUL **WHERE** YOU SHOP.
THE NONPROFIT “TOXIC-FREE FUTURE” – WHICH SPECIALIZES IN ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH RESEARCH AND ADVOCACY – HAS RELEASED IT LATEST RETAILER REPORT CARD ON THE USE OF TOXIC CHEMICALS… AND SOME OF THE MOST POPULAR NAMES ARE FEATURED IN ITS “HALL OF SHAME”.
FOR THE REPORT – TOXIC-FREE FUTURE LOOKED AT THE TOP 50 RETAILERS IN THE UNITED STATES AND CANADA AND GRADED THEM ON A SCALE OF A TO F, LIKE YOU’D SEE ON A SCHOOL REPORT CARD.
THEY LOOKED AT FOUR DIFFERENT FACTORS TO DETERMINE A RETAILER’S GRADE:
CORPORATE COMMITMENT – WHICH IS WHETHER A COMPANY HAS ADOPTED SAFER POLICIES TO AVOID USING CHEMICALS AND PLASTICS OF HIGH CONCERN.
TRANSPARENCY – WHETHER THEY’RE ASKING SUPPLIERS WHAT INGREDIENTS THEY USE IN PRODUCTS AND PACKAGING.
THEY ALSO EVALUATED WHICH RETAILERS ARE WORKING TO “BAN THE BAD” – WHICH IS EXACTLY WHAT IS SOUNDS LIKE: BANNING DANGEROUS CHEMICALS AND HARMFUL PLASTICS.
AND FINALLY – WHETHER THE COMPANY HAS IS WORKING TO FIND SAFER SOLUTIONS TO THESE HARMFUL CHEMICALS AND PLASTICS.
OF THE TOP 50 LARGEST RETAILERS… 17 SCORED A FAILING GRADE – AND ONLY FOUR MADE AN “A”.
THE RETAILERS THAT RANKED LOWEST ON THE LIST WERE ONES THAT OWNED RESTAURANTS AND DOLLAR STORE CHAINS LIKE FIVE BELOW, FAMILY DOLLAR, AND DOLLAR TREE.
THE RETAILERS THAT RECEIVED ‘A’ GRADES WERE APPLE, SEPHORA, TARGET, AND WALMART – ALL VERY POPULAR AT THIS TIME OF YEAR.
TARGET AND WALMART – WHICH ALSO OWNS POPULAR BULK CHAIN SAM’S CLUB – WERE THE ONLY GROCERY RETAILERS TO GET SUCH A HIGH GRADE.
PUBLIX AND TRADER JOE’S RECEIVED “Fs”… ALDI GOT A “D PLUS”, COSTCO AND KROGER GOT “C MINUSES,” AND WHOLE FOODS MADE A “B”.
SO, IF YOU’RE LOOKING TO MAKE MORE CONSCIENTIOUS CHOICES – THESE GRADES COULD BE SOMETHING TO CONSIDER WHEN SHOPPING FOR YOUR THANKSGIVING FEAST OR CHRISTMAS DINNER.
AND WHEN IT COMES TO SOME OF YOUR OTHER HOLIDAYGIFT GO-TOS – AMAZON AND BEST BUY MADE “Cs”.
OF, AND IF YOU NEED TO PAUSE YOUR SHOPPING SPREE FOR A MIDDAY PICK-ME-UP – JUST KNOW, STARBUCKS MADE A “D”.
FOR A LINK TO THE COMPLETE REPORT AND A BREAKDOWN OF HOW EACH RETAILER’S SCORE WAS CALCULATED, DOWNLOAD THE STRAIGHT ARROW NEWS APP NOW.
Media Landscape
See who else is reporting on this story and which side of the political spectrum they lean. To read other sources, click on the plus signs below. Learn more about this dataBias Distribution
Left
Toxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KIFIToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KVIAToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KCRA 3Toxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WCVBToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WLWTToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WMURToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WLKYToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WESHToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WDSUToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KETVToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WYFFToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WTAEToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KCCIToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KMBCToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WISNToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WBAL-TVToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WPTZToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WMTWToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WVTMToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WAPTToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KOATToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WPBFToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WGALToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WXIIToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KSBWToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on WJCLToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KHBSToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KESQToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KEYTToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KMIZToxic chemical ‘Hall of Shame’ calls out retailers in time for holiday shopping
Click to see story on KIONRight
Right
Straight to your inbox.
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.