Texas, Louisiana advance bills targeting sexually explicit books in libraries
Media Landscape
This story is a Media Miss by the right as only 8% of the coverage is from right leaning media. Learn more about this dataTWO STATES ARE LOOKING TO RESTRICT YOUTH ACCESS TO SEXUALLY EXPLICIT MATERIAL IN LIBRARIES.
BUT DEPENDING ON HOW YOU CONSUME MEDIA — YOU MAY NOT BE AWARE OF THIS.
WE START IN TEXAS — WHERE THE STATE SENATE GAVE ITS INITIAL APPROVAL TO A HOUSE BILL THAT WOULD CREATE A RATING SYSTEM FOR SCHOOL LIBRARIES.
LET’S TAKE A LOOK AT THE MEDIA LANDSCAPE ON THIS STORY — ACCORDING TO OUR EXCLUSIVE MEDIA MISS TOOL.
AS YOU CAN SEE — OUT OF THE DOZENS OF SOURCES COVERING THIS STORY — MOST ARE ON THE LEFT AND IN THE MIDDLE — AND ONLY TWO LEAN RIGHT.
WE WANT TO GIVE YOU A MORE COMPLETE PICTURE OF THE HEADLINES – USE THE TOOL FOR YOURSELF AT STRAIGHT ARROW NEWS DOT COM.
HERE’S HOW THE RATING SYSTEM WOULD WORK.
A BOOK WOULD GET A “SEXUALLY RELEVANT” RATING IF THE MATERIAL DESCRIBES OR PORTRAYS SEXUAL ACTIVITY — BUT IS PART OF THE REQUIRED SCHOOL CURRICULUM.
A BOOK WOULD GET A “SEXUALLY EXPLICIT” RATING IF THE MATERIAL DESCRIBING OR PORTRAYING SEXUAL BEHAVIOR IS “PATENTLY OFFENSIVE” — AND NOT PART OF REQUIRED CURRICULUM.
BOOKS WITH A “SEXUALLY EXPLICIT” RATING WOULD BE REMOVED FROM LIBRARY BOOKSHELVES.
STUDENTS WHO WANT TO CHECK OUT BOOKS WITH A “SEXUALLY RELEVANT” RATING WOULD HAVE TO GET PARENTAL PERMISSION FIRST.
NOW TO LOUISIANA — WHERE THE STATE HOUSE IS SET TO DEBATE A BILL THAT WOULD CREATE A CARD SYSTEM TO PREVENT CHILDREN FROM CHECKING OUT “SEXUALLY EXPLICIT MATERIAL” FROM PUBLIC LIBRARIES UNLESS THEY HAVE PARENTAL APPROVAL.
THE BILL WOULD ALLOW PARENTS TO BRING BOOKS TO A LOCAL BOARD FOR REVIEW.
LOOKING AT THE MEDIA LANDSCAPE FOR THIS STORY — MOST OF THE SOURCES LEAN LEFT — AND ONLY ONE LEANS RIGHT.
NEITHER OF THESE BILLS HAVE ADVANCED WITHOUT CONTROVERSY.
LIBRARANS — LEGAL EXPERTS AND SOME PARENTS HAVE EXPRESSED CONCERN THE TEXAS BILL’S LANGUAGE IS VAGUE AND BROAD ENOUGH TO INCLUDE BOOKS THAT ARE NOT INAPPROPRIATE.
MEANWHILE — ACTIVISTS SAY THE LOUISIANA BILL USED TO TARGET L-G-B-T-Q CONTENT.