An all-women’s college in Virginia is out with a new admission policy reported on Friday, Aug. 30, that bars transgender women from enrolling next school year, citing a document from more than 120 years ago. Sweet Briar College’s President and Chair of the school board Mary Pope Hutson said the rule stems from the legally binding will of its founder, Indiana Fletcher Williams, who died in 1900.
Media Landscape
See how news outlets across the political spectrum are covering this story. Learn more
Left 21%
Center 37%
Right 42%
Bias Distribution Powered by Ground News™
Hutson said the document requires the liberal arts school to “be a place for girls and young women.” She wrote in a letter that the phrase “must be interpreted as it was understood at the time the will was written.” The policy now requires applicants to “confirm that her sex assigned at birth is female, and that she consistently lives and identifies as a woman.”
Point phone camera here
However, the new rule sparked criticism. Many faculty members fear the guidelines will hurt already diminishing enrollment numbers. Women’s colleges have reportedly seen a decline in enrollment since the 1960s, and Sweet Briar College nearly shuttered in 2015 due to financial problems and falling enrollment.
Opponents of the new requirement also cited the board’s original interpretation of the will, which excluded non-white students. The institution had to get permission from a federal judge to accept Black students after Civil Rights Act of 1964.
Faculty voted overwhelming on Monday, Sept. 2, to rescind the admission policy.
Sweet Briar College’s Student Government Association called the policy “alienating” and “unnecessary.” The association’s president, who is nonbinary, said at least 10% of students use different pronouns and would not fit within the new policy. However, it is unclear how the admission rules would impact current students.
Hutson responded, saying that the college works to “ensure” all students “feel welcome,” adding, a “broader policy is a slippery slope toward co-education.”
Women’s colleges began to admit transgender women around a decade ago. However, at least three now bar transgender women. Private undergraduate colleges are exempt from Title IX, so, Sweet Briar College is not required to follow new rules from the Biden administration, banning discrimination based on gender identity.
Tags: College Board, college students, Discrimination, Human Rights, LGBTQ, LGBTQ Rights, Transgender, Virginia
[LAUREN TAYLOR]
AN ALL-WOMEN’S COLLEGE IN VIRGINIA IS OUT WITH A NEW ADMISSION POLICY– BARRING TRANSGENDER WOMEN FROM ENROLLING NEXT SCHOOL YEAR– CITING A DOCUMENT FROM MORE THAN 120 YEARS AGO.
SWEET BRIAR COLLEGE’S PRESIDENT AND CHAIR OF THE SCHOOL BOARD MARY POPE HUTSON SAYS THE RULE STEMS FROM THE LEGALLY BINDING WILL OF ITS FOUNDER, WHO DIED IN 1900.
THE DOCUMENT REQUIRES THE SCHOOL TO “BE A PLACE FOR GIRLS AND YOUNG WOMEN.”
HUTSON WROTE IN A LETTER THE PHRASE “MUST BE INTERPRETED AS IT WAS UNDERSTOOD AT THE TIME THE WILL WAS WRITTEN.”
THE POLICY REQUIRES APPLICANTS TO “CONFIRM THAT HER SEX ASSIGNED AT BIRTH IS FEMALE, AND THAT SHE CONSISTENTLY LIVES AND IDENTIFIES AS A WOMAN.”
THE NEW RULE IS SPARKING CRITICISM.
MANY FACULTY MEMBERS FEAR THE GUIDELINES WILL HURT ALREADY DIMINISHING ENROLLMENT NUMBERS.
WOMEN’S COLLEGES HAVE SEEN A DECLINE SINCE THE 60S AND SWEET BRIAR NEARLY SHUTTERED IN 20-15 DUE TO FINANCIAL PROBLEMS AND FALLING ENROLLMENT.
OPPONENTS ALSO CITED THE BOARD’S ORIGINAL INTERPRETATION OF THE WILL, WHICH EXCLUDED NON-WHITE STUDENTS.
THE INSTITUTION HAD TO GET PERMISSION FROM A FEDERAL JUDGE TO ACCEPT BLACK STUDENTS AFTER THE CIVIL RIGHTS ACT IN 1964.
FACULTY VOTED OVERWHELMINGLY MONDAY TO RESCIND THE POLICY– AND THE COLLEGE’S STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION RECENTLY CALLED THE POLICY “ALIENATING” AND UNNECESSARY.
THE ASSOCIATION’S PRESIDENT SAID AT LEAST 10 PERCENT OF STUDENTS USE DIFFERENT PRONOUNS AND WOULDN’T FIT WITHIN THE NEW POLICY.
IT’S UNCLEAR HOW THE ADMISSION RULES WILL IMPACT CURRENT STUDENTS.
THE UNIVERSITY PRESIDENT RESPONDED SAYING THE COLLEGE WORKS TO “ENSURE” ALL STUDENTS FEEL WELCOME.” ADDING, A “BROADER POLICY IS A SLIPPERY SLOPE TOWARD CO-EDUCATION.”
WOMEN’S COLLEGES BEGAN TO ADMIT TRANSGENDER WOMEN AROUND A DECADE AGO. AT LEAST THREE NOW BAR TRANSGENDER WOMEN– PRIVATE UNDERGRADUATE COLLEGES ARE EXEMPT FROM TITLE NINE (IX). SO, SWEET BRIAR ISN’T REQUIRED TO FOLLOW NEW RULES FROM THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION, BANNING DISCRIMINATION BASED ON GENDER IDENTITY.
WE’LL BE SURE TO CONTINUE FOLLOWING THIS STORY– AND YOU CAN TOO.
JUST DOWNLOAD THE STRAIGHT ARROW NEWS APP OR VISIT SAN DOT COM.
FOR STRAIGHT ARROW NEWS– I’M LAUREN TAYLOR.
Media Landscape
See how news outlets across the political spectrum are covering this story. Learn more
Left 21%
Center 37%
Right 42%
Bias Summary
- Ullamcorper mus risus fames nisl quam imperdiet est justo iaculis habitasse aptent, suspendisse nam rutrum suscipit ultrices blandit viverra conubia vehicula molestie.
Bias Comparison
The Left
per molestie nulla quis cras dictumst curae suspendisse placerat sapien id fusce velit parturient urna ultrices amet penatibus, dis congue tristique ridiculus praesent at augue lobortis elementum magna varius tortor mollis eros vehicula.
The Center
malesuada rhoncus risus amet praesent ad massa auctor lobortis viverra purus, mollis habitant suspendisse ex habitasse semper mattis enim ipsum.
The Right
pharetra praesent curae sodales tempor semper facilisis dapibus magnis rutrum lobortis nascetur laoreet euismod, tincidunt mollis ornare nisi habitant mattis tempus class aliquam vestibulum potenti dui.
Report an issue with this comparison
Bias Distribution
24 other sources covering this story
Total News Sources
24
Leaning Left
4
Center
7
Leaning Right
8
Last Updated
7 months ago
Bias Distribution Powered by Ground News™
Straight to your inbox.
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.
