Speaker Johnson ‘blackmailed’ into squashing remote voting resolution: Luna


Full story

  • Rep. Anna Paulina Luna said House Speaker Mike Johnson was blackmailed into squashing her resolution to allow young parents in Congress to vote remotely. She resigned from the House Freedom Caucus after stating she was “shattered” by fellow members’ actions.
  • Luna said her resolution is pro-life and pro-family, saying it’s the closest thing members of Congress would get to a maternity leave.
  • Johnson said the measure is unconstitutional, and that members of Congress must be present to vote and cannot use a proxy.

Full Story

Rep. Anna Paulina Luna, R-Fla., resigned from the House Freedom Caucus after accusing some of her fellow members of making threats and playing hardball politics to block her resolution that would allow young parents in Congress to vote remotely via proxy.

In a letter to her former caucus, she expressed dismay and disbelief. Luna also said she was “shattered” that fellow members would try to squash the bipartisan resolution that has the support of a majority of the House of Representatives. She also said House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., was “blackmailed” into sending the resolution through the rules committee in an attempt to kill it.

Luna introduced the resolution along with Reps. Sara Jacobs, D-Calif., and Brittany Pettersen, D-Colo. Supporters said there are more young parents than ever in Congress, and if they’re going to grow their families, they have to be able to keep working with an infant.

Johnson wouldn’t bring the bill up for a vote because he believes it’s unconstitutional. So, members started a discharge petition, which allows the rank-and-file to overrule the speaker and force a vote. They got 218 signatures from every political leaning, which is more than enough.

What did Luna’s statement say?

On Monday, March 31, Johnson sent Luna’s petition through the rules committee, which, on the surface, made it appear as though he was using the power of his gavel to stop it.

“In the Speaker’s defense, he is being blackmailed into doing this… but this behavior to force someone into doing something is categorically wrong and everything we are supposed to stand against,” Luna wrote in a letter to all House Republicans.

“I cannot remain in a group that would smear me as being against election integrity and extort the Speaker to derail a just cause,” Luna continued. “This is a disgraceful betrayal, a return to the manipulative tactics we have condemned, and the 119th Congress aimed to leave behind.”

Based on Luna’s account, Johnson was pressured into stopping the resolution in the way that he did. But he still opposed it and actively worked to prevent it from being approved.

Proxy voting began during COVID-19. Absent members were allowed to authorize another member to enter their vote on their behalf. Johnson said that should not happen again.

What is Johnson saying?

“The Republican Party is pro-family. We want to make it as easy as possible for young parents to be able to participate in the process. But proxy voting, in my view, is unconstitutional,” Johnson stated. “This is a deliberative body. You cannot deliberate with your colleagues if you’re out somewhere else.”

“Here’s the problem, if you create a proxy vote opportunity just for young parents, mothers and the fathers of those situations, then where is the limiting principle?” Johnson continued. 

Luna had hoped to bring the resolution up for a vote as early as this week. Now, its future is uncertain, and despite a majority of the chamber signing a petition to support it, it may never get a vote.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Bias comparison

  • Media outlets on the left framed the Freedom Caucus as holding Speaker Johnson "hostage" and acting "disingenuously," emphasizing the "shattered" respect and portraying Luna's exit as a consequence of the caucus's extreme actions.
  • Not enough coverage from media outlets in the center to provide a bias comparison.
  • Media outlets on the right highlighted Luna's perspective, emphasizing the "shattered" mutual respect and portraying conservative lawmakers as "twisting Speaker Johnson's arm," while also detailing internal Freedom Caucus dynamics and a judge's ruling against COVID-era proxy voting.

Media landscape

Click on bars to see headlines

43 total sources

Key points from the Left

  • Representative Anna Paulina Luna of Florida left the House Freedom Caucus due to disagreements over remote voting for new parents around the birth of a child, according to her letter obtained by CBS News.
  • House Speaker Mike Johnson opposes proxy voting, calling it unconstitutional, and indicated efforts to block Luna's proposal, as reported by Luna.
  • A small group within the Freedom Caucus allegedly threatened to prevent House proceedings if Johnson did not change rules to block Luna's proposal, according to her letter.
  • The House is set to vote on measures that could effectively halt the discharge petition, despite some Republicans showing private support for Luna's initiative.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Right

  • Rep. Anna Paulina Luna announced her departure from the House Freedom Caucus due to disagreements over her proposal for parental proxy voting, stating it went against the group's core values.
  • Luna's proposal received bipartisan support, but House Republicans, led by Congressman Chip Roy, opposed it, demanding adherence to the Constitution's quorum clause.
  • Luna's discharge petition, requiring 218 signatures, was aimed at forcing a vote on her bill, which would allow new parents to vote by proxy.
  • In her resignation letter, Luna criticized the caucus for engaging in backroom deals and misrepresenting her to the public.

Report an issue with this summary

Powered by Ground News™

Full story

  • Rep. Anna Paulina Luna said House Speaker Mike Johnson was blackmailed into squashing her resolution to allow young parents in Congress to vote remotely. She resigned from the House Freedom Caucus after stating she was “shattered” by fellow members’ actions.
  • Luna said her resolution is pro-life and pro-family, saying it’s the closest thing members of Congress would get to a maternity leave.
  • Johnson said the measure is unconstitutional, and that members of Congress must be present to vote and cannot use a proxy.

Full Story

Rep. Anna Paulina Luna, R-Fla., resigned from the House Freedom Caucus after accusing some of her fellow members of making threats and playing hardball politics to block her resolution that would allow young parents in Congress to vote remotely via proxy.

In a letter to her former caucus, she expressed dismay and disbelief. Luna also said she was “shattered” that fellow members would try to squash the bipartisan resolution that has the support of a majority of the House of Representatives. She also said House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., was “blackmailed” into sending the resolution through the rules committee in an attempt to kill it.

Luna introduced the resolution along with Reps. Sara Jacobs, D-Calif., and Brittany Pettersen, D-Colo. Supporters said there are more young parents than ever in Congress, and if they’re going to grow their families, they have to be able to keep working with an infant.

Johnson wouldn’t bring the bill up for a vote because he believes it’s unconstitutional. So, members started a discharge petition, which allows the rank-and-file to overrule the speaker and force a vote. They got 218 signatures from every political leaning, which is more than enough.

What did Luna’s statement say?

On Monday, March 31, Johnson sent Luna’s petition through the rules committee, which, on the surface, made it appear as though he was using the power of his gavel to stop it.

“In the Speaker’s defense, he is being blackmailed into doing this… but this behavior to force someone into doing something is categorically wrong and everything we are supposed to stand against,” Luna wrote in a letter to all House Republicans.

“I cannot remain in a group that would smear me as being against election integrity and extort the Speaker to derail a just cause,” Luna continued. “This is a disgraceful betrayal, a return to the manipulative tactics we have condemned, and the 119th Congress aimed to leave behind.”

Based on Luna’s account, Johnson was pressured into stopping the resolution in the way that he did. But he still opposed it and actively worked to prevent it from being approved.

Proxy voting began during COVID-19. Absent members were allowed to authorize another member to enter their vote on their behalf. Johnson said that should not happen again.

What is Johnson saying?

“The Republican Party is pro-family. We want to make it as easy as possible for young parents to be able to participate in the process. But proxy voting, in my view, is unconstitutional,” Johnson stated. “This is a deliberative body. You cannot deliberate with your colleagues if you’re out somewhere else.”

“Here’s the problem, if you create a proxy vote opportunity just for young parents, mothers and the fathers of those situations, then where is the limiting principle?” Johnson continued. 

Luna had hoped to bring the resolution up for a vote as early as this week. Now, its future is uncertain, and despite a majority of the chamber signing a petition to support it, it may never get a vote.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Bias comparison

  • Media outlets on the left framed the Freedom Caucus as holding Speaker Johnson "hostage" and acting "disingenuously," emphasizing the "shattered" respect and portraying Luna's exit as a consequence of the caucus's extreme actions.
  • Not enough coverage from media outlets in the center to provide a bias comparison.
  • Media outlets on the right highlighted Luna's perspective, emphasizing the "shattered" mutual respect and portraying conservative lawmakers as "twisting Speaker Johnson's arm," while also detailing internal Freedom Caucus dynamics and a judge's ruling against COVID-era proxy voting.

Media landscape

Click on bars to see headlines

43 total sources

Key points from the Left

  • Representative Anna Paulina Luna of Florida left the House Freedom Caucus due to disagreements over remote voting for new parents around the birth of a child, according to her letter obtained by CBS News.
  • House Speaker Mike Johnson opposes proxy voting, calling it unconstitutional, and indicated efforts to block Luna's proposal, as reported by Luna.
  • A small group within the Freedom Caucus allegedly threatened to prevent House proceedings if Johnson did not change rules to block Luna's proposal, according to her letter.
  • The House is set to vote on measures that could effectively halt the discharge petition, despite some Republicans showing private support for Luna's initiative.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Right

  • Rep. Anna Paulina Luna announced her departure from the House Freedom Caucus due to disagreements over her proposal for parental proxy voting, stating it went against the group's core values.
  • Luna's proposal received bipartisan support, but House Republicans, led by Congressman Chip Roy, opposed it, demanding adherence to the Constitution's quorum clause.
  • Luna's discharge petition, requiring 218 signatures, was aimed at forcing a vote on her bill, which would allow new parents to vote by proxy.
  • In her resignation letter, Luna criticized the caucus for engaging in backroom deals and misrepresenting her to the public.

Report an issue with this summary

Powered by Ground News™