Skip to main content
International

Scottish law criminalizes hate speech online; complaint filed against JK Rowling

Media Landscape

See who else is reporting on this story and which side of the political spectrum they lean. To read other sources, click on the plus signs below. Learn more about this data
Left 38% Center 14% Right 48%
Bias Distribution Powered by Ground News

New, controversial hate crime laws will go into effect April 1 in Scotland. The purpose of the laws is to better protect people from hateful speech, including online, but critics of the laws say it infringes on freedom of expression.

The law will criminalize threatening or abusive behavior which is intended to stir up hate against someone because of their age, religion, sexual orientation and transgender identity.

QR code for SAN app download

Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.

Point phone camera here

The hate crime can be verbal, physical or in a digital space, meaning hate speech online will become a criminal offense.

Scottish authorities have pledged the hate crime laws will be enforced to the fullest extent. Police said they will investigate every complaint they receive.

One complaint has already been filed ahead of the law’s implementation against J.K. Rowling, the author of the “Harry Potter” series, who has been vocal in her criticism of the transgender movement.

Rowling referred to transgender TV broadcaster India Willoughby as a man, despite Willoughby identifying as a woman.

However, local police said Rowling’s comments on X, formerly Twitter, did not meet the criminal threshold for prosecution.

Enforcing the new hate crime laws has been a concern from both advocates and critics. The Scottish Police Federation, the union that represents police officers, called it a “recipe for disaster.”

A spokesperson for the federation said police are already overwhelmed before the new law takes effect and the training to enforce the new laws was vague. The union representative also expressed worries that online insults would inundate their police force.

Tags: , , , , ,

NEW, CONTROVERSIAL HATE CRIME LAWS WILL GO INTO EFFECT APRIL FIRST IN SCOTLAND.

THEIR PURPOSE IS TO BETTER PROTECT PEOPLE FROM HATEFUL SPEECH –

INCLUDING ONLINE.

BUT CRITICS OF THE LAW SAY IT INFRINGES ON FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION.

THE LAW WILL CRIMINALIZE “THREATENING OR ABUSIVE BEHAVIOR WHICH IS INTENDED TO STIR UP HATE AGAINST SOMEONE BECAUSE OF THEIR AGE, RELIGION, SEXUAL ORIENTATION, AND TRANSGENDER IDENTITY.”

THE HATE CRIME CAN BE VERBAL. PHYSICAL. OR DIGITAL – MEANING HATE SPEECH ONLINE WOULD BE A CRIMINAL OFFENSE.

SCOTLAND POLICE RELEASING THIS VIDEO AHEAD OF THE LAW TAKING PLACE –

REMINDING PEOPLE TO KEEP “THE HATE MONSTER” AT BAY OR PAY THE PRICE.

SCOTLAND AUTHORITIES HAVE PLEDGED THE HATE CRIME LAWS WILL BE ENFORCED TO THE FULLEST EXTENT.

POLICE SAY THEY’LL INVESTIGATE “EVERY COMPLAINT IT RECEIVES.”

AND ALLEGATIONS CAN BE MADE ANONYMOUSLY TOO.

ONE COMPLAINT HAS ALREADY BEEN FILED AHEAD OF THE LAW GOING INTO EFFECT IN TWO WEEKS.

IT WAS AGAINST J.K. ROWLING – THE AUTHOR OF HARRY POTTER – WHO HAS BEEN VOCAL IN HER CRITICISM OF THE TRANSGENDER MOVEMENT.

ROWLING CALLED TRANSGENDER T.V. BROADCASTER “INDIA WILLOUGHBY” A “MAN” WHEN THE BROADCASTER IDENTIFIES AS A WOMAN.

ROWLING SAID IN A POST ON X.

QUOTE – “If you genuinely imagine I’d delete posts calling a man a man, so as not to be prosecuted under this ludicrous law, stand by for the mother of all April Fools’ jokes.”

LOCAL POLICE SAY ROWLING’S COMMENTS DIDN’T “meet the criminal threshold” FOR PROSECUTION.

WILLOUGHBY POSTED – The law is absolutely on my side – but it has been so disappointing to see the police refusing to prosecute fully. I suspect because it’s JK Rowling, and the Home Secretary and Daily Mail would be calling for their heads. Power made them bottle it.”

ENFORCING THE NEW HATE CRIME LAWS HAS BEEN A CONCERN FROM THE START.

“THE SCOTTISH POLICE FEDERATION” WHICH IS THE UNION THAT REPRESENTS POLICE OFFICERS – CALLED IT “A RECIPE FOR DISASTER.”

SAYING POLICE ARE ALREADY OVERWHELMED EVEN BEFORE THE NEW LAW TAKES EFFECT.

THE TRAINING WAS VAGUE ACCORDING TO THE UNION SPOKESPERSON.

AND THEY WORRY ONLINE INSULTS WILL FLOOD THEIR PHONE LINES.