Reaction to conservative Supreme Court justices secretly recorded at Gala
By Karah Rucker (Anchor/Reporter), Zachary Hill (Video Editor)
A recent undercover operation by liberal activist Lauren Windsor, who posed as a Catholic conservative at a charity event, has brought new scrutiny to the U.S. Supreme Court. Windsor, known for covertly recording prominent Republicans, secretly recorded conversations with conservative Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito and Chief Justice John Roberts.
Media Landscape
See who else is reporting on this story and which side of the political spectrum they lean. To read other sources, click on the plus signs below. Learn more about this dataBias Distribution
Left
Alito Says One Side Of Political Fight Is ‘Going To Win,’ Private Event Recordings Reveal
Click to see story on HuffPostJustice Alito Caught on Tape Discussing How Battle for America ‘Can’t Be Compromised’
Click to see story on RollingStoneSecret recording: Alito says no compromise for ‘fundamental’ moral differences
Click to see story on AlternetSamuel Alito Gets Remarkably Candid in Secret Audio Recording
Click to see story on The Daily BeastCaught on Tape, Alito Exposed as ‘Crusader for Christian Nationalism’
Click to see story on Common DreamsSamuel Alito Declares One Side Will Win in Secret Bombshell Recording
Click to see story on The New RepublicSupreme Court Justice Samuel Alito Caught on Secret Audio
Click to see story on The InterceptSecret Recording: Alito Caught on Tape Declaring ‘One Side Must Win’ in Ideological War For America And ‘It Can’t Be Compromised’
Click to see story on The Daily BoulderJustice Alito ‘agrees’ in recording that US should return to ‘place of godliness’
Click to see story on The IndependentU.S. Supreme Court Justice Alito questions if left and right can compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on CBC NewsJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on Associated Press NewsJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on abc NewsThe Alitos and Roberts discuss politically sensitive topics in secret recordings by liberal activist
Click to see story on CNNJustice Alito talked about political divide on purported secret recordings
Click to see story on The Washington PostJustice Samuel Alito recorded making controversial remarks that call compromise into question
Click to see story on NY Daily NewsSupreme Court justices Alito and Roberts discuss politically sensitive topics in secret recordings by liberal activist
Click to see story on The Mercury newsThe secret recordings of Alito and Roberts will likely backfire
Click to see story on Business InsiderJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on Star TribuneThe Alitos and Roberts discuss politically sensitive topics in secret recordings by liberal activist – Boston News, Weather, Sports
Click to see story on WHDHAlito and his wife are captured in audio recordings talking about abortion leak, flag controversy
Click to see story on PoliticoJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording – WSVN 7News | Miami News, Weather, Sports
Click to see story on WSVNJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on AJCJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on The Seattle TimesSupreme Court Justice Samuel Alito caught on secret recording
Click to see story on NBC WashingtonJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on WCSHThe Alitos and Roberts discuss politically sensitive topics in secret recordings by liberal activist
Click to see story on KRDOThe Alitos and Roberts discuss politically sensitive topics in secret recordings by liberal activist
Click to see story on KIFIThe Alitos and Roberts discuss politically sensitive topics in secret recordings by liberal activist
Click to see story on KVIAAlito, Roberts secretly recorded at historical society dinner
Click to see story on The HillJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on Winnipeg Free PressSamuel Alito slams criticism of Supreme Court in secret recording
Click to see story on NewsweekJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recordings
Click to see story on Washington Top NewsJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recordings
Click to see story on WPLGJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on News 4 JAXJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on Pioneer PressJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recordings
Click to see story on WKMGJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on Click on DetroitJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on San Diego Union TribuneAlito Caught on Tape Discussing Battle for America
Click to see story on Political WireSupreme Court’s Alito appears to back US return to ‘godliness’ in secret recording
Click to see story on WTVBJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on KOB 4Samuel Alito caught on secret recording: There’s no compromising
Click to see story on njThe Alitos and Roberts discuss politically sensitive topics in secret recordings by liberal activist
Click to see story on KWWLJustice Alito questions political compromise in recording
Click to see story on NY1Justice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on KCRGJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recordings
Click to see story on KDVRJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on WSPAJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on WKYCSecret recording of Justice Samuel Alito raises questions about impartiality of Supreme Court
Click to see story on Scripps NewsLiberal activist secretly records Justices Alito, Roberts
Click to see story on Washington TimesAlito and Roberts secretly recorded in latest attempt to undermine Supreme Court
Click to see story on Washington ExaminerJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on National PostJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on Boston HeraldActivist releases secret recordings of SCOTUS justices, including Alito on probe of Dobbs leak
Click to see story on Just the NewsJustice Alito talked about political divide on purported secret recordings
Click to see story on New Hampshire Union LeaderChief Justice Roberts and Justice Alito Secretly Recorded at the Supreme Court Historical Society
Click to see story on ReasonUntracked Bias
Justice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on Shropshire StarJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on My Mother LodeJustice Alito and the Quest for Godliness: An Undercover Revelation
Click to see story on DevdiscourseJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on nashvilleledger.comThe release of this audio has reignited debates over the court’s credibility, coinciding with the anticipated rulings on several high-profile cases in June.
“As a Catholic and as someone who like really cherishes my faith, I just don’t, I don’t know that we can negotiate with the left in the way that needs to happen for the polarization to end,” Windsor said to Alito. “I think it’s a matter of like, winning.”
Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.
Point phone camera here
“I think you’re probably right,” Alito responded. “On one side or the other — one side or the other is going to win. I don’t know. I mean, there can be a way of working, a way of living together peacefully, but it’s difficult, you know, because there are differences on fundamental things that really can’t be compromised. They really can’t be compromised. So, it’s not like you are going to split the difference.”
“People in this country who believe in God have got to keep fighting for that, to return our country to a place of godliness,” Windsor said.
“Well I agree with you,” Alito said. “I agree with you.”
These remarks have led some Democrats to question whether personal beliefs might influence judicial decisions on politically sensitive cases.
Justice Roberts, however, defended the court’s role, emphasizing its duty to decide cases impartially.
“You don’t think there’s, like, a role for the court in guiding us toward a more moral path?” Windsor asked Roberts.
“No, I think the role for the court is deciding the cases,” Roberts said. “If I start — would you want me to be in charge of guiding us toward a more moral path? That’s for the people we elect. That’s not for lawyers.”
“I believe that the founders were godly, were Christians, and I think that we live in a Christian nation, and that our Supreme Court should be guiding us in that path,” Windsor said.
“I don’t know if that’s true,” Roberts said. “I don’t know that we live in a Christian nation. I know a lot of Jewish and Muslim friends who would say, ‘Maybe not,’ and it’s not our job to do that. It’s our job to decide the cases as best we can.”
Sen. Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., has been vocal calling for Supreme Court ethics reform. He criticized Justice Alito, saying, “Alito is becoming a loose cannon turned on the court itself. He mocks ethics.”
Unbiased news.
Directly to your inbox. Free!
Learn more about our emails. Unsubscribe anytime.
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.
In contrast, conservative advocacy groups like the Judicial Crisis Network released a statement dismissing the recordings as “pure click bait” and said there was nothing inappropriate in the justices’ comments.
The Supreme Court Historical Society, which hosted the event where the recordings took place, condemned Windsor’s undercover tactics. Windsor defended her actions, citing the legality of her recordings under Washington’s one-party consent law. She argued that the Supreme Court “has been shrouded in secrecy and refuses any degree of accountability.”
[KARAH RUCKER]
A LIBERAL ACTIVIST WENT UNDERCOVER AT A CHARITY EVENT – POSING AS A CATHOLIC CONSERVATIVE – WHILE SECRETLY RECORDING CONVERSATIONS SHE HAD WITH CONSERVATIVE SUPREME COURT JUSTICES.
THE NEWLY RELEASED AUDIO TAPES ARE ONCE AGAIN FUELING CREDIBILITY CONCERNS OVER THE HIGH COURT.
THE TIMING OF THE LATEST CONTROVERSY COMES AS THE JUSTICES ARE EXPECTED TO RULE ON SEVERAL HIGH PROFILE CASES THIS MONTH.
LAUREN WINDSOR IS KNOWN FOR SECRETLY RECORDING REPUBLICANS WHILE PRETENDING TO BE ONE HERSELF.
JIM JORDAN.
MIKE PENCE.
MATT GAETZ BEING SOME OF HER HIGH-PROFILE REPUBLICAN TARGETS.
THE LATEST TO BE CAUGHT ON WINDSOR’S RECORDER –
JUSTICE SAMUEL ALITO AND CHIEF JUSTICE JOHN ROBERTS.
HERE ARE A FEW PORTIONS OF THE EXCHANGE BETWEEN WINDSOR AND ALITO GARNERING THE MOST ATTENTION.
Windsor:
“As a catholic and as someone who like really cherishes my faith, I just don’t, I don’t know that we can negotiate with the left in the way that needs to happen for the polarization to end. I think it’s a matter of like, winning.”
Alito:
I think you’re probably right. On one side or the other, one side or the other is going to win. I don’t know. I mean there can be a way of working, a way of living together peacefully, but it’s difficult, you know, because there are difference on fundamental issues that can’t be compromised.”
Windsor:
“People in this country who believe in God have got to keep fighting for that, to return our country to a place of godliness.”
Alito:
“Well I agree with you. I agree with you.”
[KARAH RUCKER]
SOME DEMOCRATS QUESTION WHETHER A JUSTICE’S PERSONAL BELIEFS MIGHT LEAD TO BIAS INTO THEIR RULINGS OVER POLITICALLY CHARGED CASES.
JUSTICE ROBERTS –
WAS QUICK TO DEFEND THE COURT’S INTEGRITY IN ANOTHER SECRETLY RECORDED EXCHANGE.
Windsor:
“But you don’t think there’s like, a role for the court in like guiding us toward a more moral path?”
Roberts:
“No, i think the role for the court is deciding the cases. If i start – would you want me to be in charge of guiding us toward a more moral path? That’s for the people we elect. That’s not for lawyers.”
Windsor:
“Well i guess i just, i believe that the founders were godly, like were christians, and i think that we live in a christian nation and that our supreme court should be guiding us in that path.”
Roberts:
I don’t know if thats true. I don’t know that we live in a christian nation.I know a lot of Jewish and Muslim friends who would say, maybe not, and its not our job to do that. Its our job to decide the cases as best we can.”
[KARAH RUCKER]
SENATOR RICHARD BLUMENTHAL HAS BEEN VOCAL IN WANTING A SUPREME COURT ETHICS REFORM.
REACTING TO THE RELEASED AUDIO HE SAYS –
“ALITO IS BECOMING A LOOSE CANNON TURNED ON THE COURT ITSELF. HE MOCKS ETHICS.”
MEANWHILE CONSERVATIVE ADVOCACY GROUPS HAVE CALLED IT
“PURE CLICK BAIT.” SAYING “NOTHING IN THIS AUDIO OF CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS AND JUSTICE ALITO IS REMOTELY INAPPROPRIATE.”
THE SUPREME COURT HISTORICAL SOCIETY WHICH HOSTED THE GALA WHERE THE SECRET RECORDINGS TOOK PLACE CONDEMNED THE UNDERCOVER RUSE.
WHILE WINDSOR HAS SINCE DEFENDED HER ACTIONS.
THE RECORDINGS WERE **LEGAL UNDER WASHINGTON D.C.’S LAW REGARDING ONE PARTY CONSENT TO RECORD.
AND SHE SAYS THE SUPREME COURT HAS BEEN “SHROUDED IN SECRECY AND REFUSES ANY DEGREE OF ACCOUNTABILITY.”
Related
Media Landscape
See who else is reporting on this story and which side of the political spectrum they lean. To read other sources, click on the plus signs below. Learn more about this dataBias Distribution
Left
Alito Says One Side Of Political Fight Is ‘Going To Win,’ Private Event Recordings Reveal
Click to see story on HuffPostJustice Alito Caught on Tape Discussing How Battle for America ‘Can’t Be Compromised’
Click to see story on RollingStoneSecret recording: Alito says no compromise for ‘fundamental’ moral differences
Click to see story on AlternetSamuel Alito Gets Remarkably Candid in Secret Audio Recording
Click to see story on The Daily BeastCaught on Tape, Alito Exposed as ‘Crusader for Christian Nationalism’
Click to see story on Common DreamsSamuel Alito Declares One Side Will Win in Secret Bombshell Recording
Click to see story on The New RepublicSupreme Court Justice Samuel Alito Caught on Secret Audio
Click to see story on The InterceptSecret Recording: Alito Caught on Tape Declaring ‘One Side Must Win’ in Ideological War For America And ‘It Can’t Be Compromised’
Click to see story on The Daily BoulderJustice Alito ‘agrees’ in recording that US should return to ‘place of godliness’
Click to see story on The IndependentU.S. Supreme Court Justice Alito questions if left and right can compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on CBC NewsJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on Associated Press NewsJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on abc NewsThe Alitos and Roberts discuss politically sensitive topics in secret recordings by liberal activist
Click to see story on CNNJustice Alito talked about political divide on purported secret recordings
Click to see story on The Washington PostJustice Samuel Alito recorded making controversial remarks that call compromise into question
Click to see story on NY Daily NewsSupreme Court justices Alito and Roberts discuss politically sensitive topics in secret recordings by liberal activist
Click to see story on The Mercury newsThe secret recordings of Alito and Roberts will likely backfire
Click to see story on Business InsiderJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on Star TribuneThe Alitos and Roberts discuss politically sensitive topics in secret recordings by liberal activist – Boston News, Weather, Sports
Click to see story on WHDHAlito and his wife are captured in audio recordings talking about abortion leak, flag controversy
Click to see story on PoliticoJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording – WSVN 7News | Miami News, Weather, Sports
Click to see story on WSVNJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on AJCJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on The Seattle TimesSupreme Court Justice Samuel Alito caught on secret recording
Click to see story on NBC WashingtonJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on WCSHThe Alitos and Roberts discuss politically sensitive topics in secret recordings by liberal activist
Click to see story on KRDOThe Alitos and Roberts discuss politically sensitive topics in secret recordings by liberal activist
Click to see story on KIFIThe Alitos and Roberts discuss politically sensitive topics in secret recordings by liberal activist
Click to see story on KVIAAlito, Roberts secretly recorded at historical society dinner
Click to see story on The HillJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on Winnipeg Free PressSamuel Alito slams criticism of Supreme Court in secret recording
Click to see story on NewsweekJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recordings
Click to see story on Washington Top NewsJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recordings
Click to see story on WPLGJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on News 4 JAXJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on Pioneer PressJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recordings
Click to see story on WKMGJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on Click on DetroitJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on San Diego Union TribuneAlito Caught on Tape Discussing Battle for America
Click to see story on Political WireSupreme Court’s Alito appears to back US return to ‘godliness’ in secret recording
Click to see story on WTVBJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on KOB 4Samuel Alito caught on secret recording: There’s no compromising
Click to see story on njThe Alitos and Roberts discuss politically sensitive topics in secret recordings by liberal activist
Click to see story on KWWLJustice Alito questions political compromise in recording
Click to see story on NY1Justice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on KCRGJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recordings
Click to see story on KDVRJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on WSPAJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on WKYCSecret recording of Justice Samuel Alito raises questions about impartiality of Supreme Court
Click to see story on Scripps NewsLiberal activist secretly records Justices Alito, Roberts
Click to see story on Washington TimesAlito and Roberts secretly recorded in latest attempt to undermine Supreme Court
Click to see story on Washington ExaminerJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on National PostJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on Boston HeraldActivist releases secret recordings of SCOTUS justices, including Alito on probe of Dobbs leak
Click to see story on Just the NewsJustice Alito talked about political divide on purported secret recordings
Click to see story on New Hampshire Union LeaderChief Justice Roberts and Justice Alito Secretly Recorded at the Supreme Court Historical Society
Click to see story on ReasonUntracked Bias
Justice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on Shropshire StarJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on My Mother LodeJustice Alito and the Quest for Godliness: An Undercover Revelation
Click to see story on DevdiscourseJustice Alito questions possibility of political compromise in secret recording
Click to see story on nashvilleledger.comVOTE WITH THE UNBIASED, STRAIGHT FACTS.™
We promise you context and clarity when it matters the most!
Unbiased news.
Directly to
your inbox.
Free!