Two years after an Ivy League student’s death put the spotlight on a caffeinated beverage from Panera Bread, her family has settled with the restaurant chain. The family of Sarah Katz, a 21-year-old University of Pennsylvania student at the time of her death, reached a settlement Monday, Oct. 7, just days before the case was headed for trial.
Media Landscape
This story is a Media Miss by the right as only 10% of the coverage is from right leaning media. Learn more
Left 50%
Center 40%
Right 10%
Bias Distribution Powered by Ground News™
The family’s lawyer, Elizabeth Crawford with the law firm Kline and Specter, told Straight Arrow News “the matter has been resolved.” Crawford added she could not comment any further.
According to the wrongful death lawsuit filed in Philadelphia last year, Katz avoided energy drinks because of a heart condition, but ordered Panera’s Charged Lemonade not knowing its high levels of caffeine.
Point phone camera here
The suit claimed the drink was not properly labeled, described at the time as a “plant-based” option. Katz went into cardiac arrest at the restaurant and later died at the hospital.
A large cup of the beverage contained about 390 milligrams of caffeine, and FDA said a safe quantity of caffeine for healthy adults is typically around 400 milligrams a day.
After Katz’s family filed its lawsuit, more allegations emerged concerning the drink.
The family of 46-year-old Dennis Brown of Florida, who lived with a chromosomal deficiency disorder and high blood pressure, sued Panera after he drank the Charged Lemonade and suffered cardiac arrest on his walk home. He died at the scene.
In response, Panera responded the suits had no merit. However, the company would later make changes by adding warnings to the drink’s online description: “Contains caffeine. Use in moderation. Not recommended for children, people sensitive to caffeine, pregnant or nursing women.”
Get up to speed on the stories leading the day every weekday morning. Sign up for the newsletter today!
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.
Earlier this year, Panera announced it was pulling the controversial beverages from its restaurants nationwide citing a menu revamp.
Like Katz, the firm of Kline and Specter also represents Brown and two other plaintiffs who had no underlying health conditions but claim Panera’s Charged Lemonade caused heart injuries.
Straight Arrow News has reached out to Panera for a comment on the settlement.
[KARAH RUCKER]
TWO YEARS AFTER AN IVY LEAGUE STUDENT’S DEATH PUT THE SPOTLIGHT ON A CAFFEINATED BEVERAGE FROM PANERA BREAD, HER FAMILY HAS SETTLED WITH THE RESTAURANT CHAIN.
THE FAMILY OF 21-YEAR-OLD UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA STUDENT SARAH KATZ REACHING A SETTLEMENT JUST DAYS BEFORE THE CASE WAS HEADED FOR TRIAL.
THE FAMILY’S LAWYER — ELIZABETH CRAWFORD WITH THE LAW FIRM KLINE AND SPECTER — TELLING STRAIGHT ARROW NEWS MONDAY — QUOTE “THE MATTER HAS BEEN RESOLVED” BUT ADDED SHE COULD NOT COMMENT ANY FURTHER.
ACCORDING TO A LAWSUIT FILED IN PHILADELPHIA LAST YEAR — KATZ AVOIDED ENERGY DRINKS BECAUSE OF A HEART CONDITION – BUT ORDERED PANERA’S CHARGED LEMONADE NOT KNOWING ITS HIGH LEVELS OF CAFFEINE.
THE SUIT CLAIMED THE DRINK WAS NOT PROPERLY LABELED, DESCRIBED AT THE TIME AS A “PLANT-BASED” OPTION, AND KATZ GOING INTO CARDIAC ARREST AT THE RESTAURANT – LATER DYING AT THE HOSPITAL.
A LARGE CUP OF THE BEVERAGE CONTAINED ABOUT 390 MILLIGRAMS OF CAFFEINE – WHILE THE FDA SAYS A SAFE QUANTITY OF CAFFEINE FOR HEALTHY ADULTS IS TYPICALLY AROUND 400 MILLIGRAMS – A DAY.
AFTER KATZ’S FAMILY FILED ITS LAWSUIT – MORE ALLEGATIONS EMERGED CONCERNING THE DRINK.
THE FAMILY OF 46-YEAR-OLD DENNIS BROWN OF FLORIDA WHO LIVED WITH A CHROMOSOMAL DEFICIENCY DISORDER AND HIGH BLOOD PRESSURE SUED PANERA AFTER HE DRANK THE CHARGED LEMONADE AND SUFFERED CARDIAC ARREST ON HIS WALK HOME. HE DIED AT THE SCENE.
IN RESPONSE TO THE LAWSUITS – PANERA RESPONDED THAT THEY HAD NO MERIT – BUT THE COMPANY WOULD LATER MAKE CHANGES – ADDING WARNINGS TO THE DRINK’S ONLINE DESCRIPTION – LIKE “CONTAINS CAFFEINE” “USE IN MODERATION” AND “NOT RECOMMENDED FOR CHILDREN, PEOPLE SENSITIVE TO CAFFEINE, PREGNANT OR NURSING WOMEN.”
THEN EARLIER THIS YEAR – CITING A REVAMPED MENU – PANERA ANNOUNCING IT WAS PULLING THE CONTROVERSIAL BEVERAGES FROM ITS RESTAURANTS NATIONWIDE.
LIKE KATZ, THE FIRM OF KLINE AND SPECTER ALSO REPRESENTS BROWN AND TWO OTHER PLAINTIFFS WHO HAD NO UNDERLYING HEALTH CONDITIONS BUT CLAIM PANERA’S CHARGED LEMONADE CAUSED HEART INJURIES.
STRAIGHT ARROW NEWS HAS REACHED OUT TO PANERA FOR A COMMENT ON THE SETTLEMENT.
FOR STRAIGHT ARROW NEWS, I’M KARAH RUCKER. FOR MORE OF OUR STORIES DOWNLOAD THE STRAIGHT ARROW NEWS APP OR VISIT OUR WEBSITE SAN-DOT-COM.
Media Landscape
This story is a Media Miss by the right as only 10% of the coverage is from right leaning media. Learn more
Left 50%
Center 40%
Right 10%
Bias Summary
- Risus mus taciti pharetra mauris odio eleifend torquent semper congue felis consectetur sit cubilia litora, imperdiet sollicitudin nunc phasellus dignissim purus venenatis gravida pellentesque condimentum etiam habitant natoque.
- Cursus tincidunt class lorem aliquet curae pharetra est suspendisse ullamcorper sit vestibulum, turpis convallis elit etiam potenti nullam commodo ultricies dapibus dignissim.
- Ornare varius sociosqu litora lorem praesent augue posuere duis nulla dapibus justo tellus interdum vehicula, torquent dis aptent imperdiet vestibulum convallis vulputate sodales commodo euismod volutpat leo.
Bias Comparison
The Left
nibh diam natoque cubilia ex orci nostra porttitor magna primis, pretium ultricies nec id facilisi condimentum tempus.
The Center
aenean turpis tempus nullam amet porttitor rutrum ut praesent cras molestie, ipsum iaculis vel sapien augue metus interdum facilisi id faucibus, torquent pulvinar fusce dictum et magna sit sagittis posuere.
Report an issue with this comparison
Bias Distribution
13 other sources covering this story
Total News Sources
13
Leaning Left
5
Center
4
Leaning Right
1
Last Updated
6 months ago
Bias Distribution Powered by Ground News™
Straight to your inbox.
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.
