
Lawsuit alleges first deaths from 2023 Ohio train derailment disaster
By Craig Nigrelli (Anchor), Evan Hummel (Producer), Kaleb Gillespie (Video Editor)
- A new lawsuit is claiming for the first time people died as a result of the 2023 East Palestine, Ohio train derailment disaster.
- The wrongful death lawsuit does not describe the deaths but says among those who died are a 1-week-old baby.
- The lawsuit also accuses the rail company and its contractors of mishandling cleanup efforts.
Vice President JD Vance and the new head of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Lee Zeldin, are visiting East Palestine, Ohio, on Monday, Feb. 3, to mark two years since the train derailment. Vance and Zeldin’s visit comes on the heels of a new lawsuit that claims for the first time people died as a result of the train derailment’s aftermath.
Media Landscape
See how news outlets across the political spectrum are covering this story. Learn moreBias Summary
- Inceptos quisque cubilia egestas sollicitudin eu senectus ligula nam, aliquet dapibus libero purus suscipit a felis.
- Vehicula primis sapien eros feugiat velit suspendisse nunc eu parturient phasellus rutrum ultricies ipsum posuere adipiscing, vestibulum gravida ornare vel cubilia convallis lobortis lectus class amet odio facilisi habitant iaculis.
- Dapibus consequat ante vestibulum ornare diam vel pharetra purus conubia sociosqu condimentum habitant per, cursus elit metus odio nisi nam venenatis accumsan pellentesque libero adipiscing porttitor.
- Turpis nulla commodo ligula lorem tellus est massa himenaeos nisi blandit class magnis justo adipiscing nullam porta tincidunt, consectetur senectus torquent vehicula sed ex cubilia auctor viverra per eros nam condimentum bibendum nascetur.
- Netus malesuada aliquam sodales lectus ut fusce nec maximus pulvinar curabitur, leo nisi urna condimentum efficitur per pretium elementum.
Bias Comparison
Bias Distribution
Left
Right
Untracked Bias
What does the latest lawsuit claim?
The new lawsuit contains the first of seven wrongful death claims filed against Norfolk Southern, including the death of a 1-week-old infant. It also accuses the railroad and its contractors of mishandling cleanup efforts while the EPA and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) signed off on them and failed to tell residents about the health risks.
Court documents describe some of the lingering health problems, however, they do not include details about the deaths.

Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.
Point phone camera here
Are there other lawsuits?
The court filings follow a flurry of recent lawsuits from individuals and businesses that argue a $600-million class-action lawsuit does not offer enough money to cover future expenses linked to the disaster or to prevent another derailment.
What happened two years ago?
On Feb. 3, 2023, dozens of railcars went off the tracks, including some cars carrying toxic materials. Five of the cars contained vinyl chloride. Officials decided to burn the railcars over fears of an explosion.
As a result, spewing toxic plumes of smoke into the East Palestine area. A later investigation revealed that the decision to burn the cars was unnecessary and misguided.
Get up to speed on the stories leading the day every weekday morning. Sign up for the newsletter today!
Learn more about our emails. Unsubscribe anytime.
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.
How are the defendants responding to the allegations?
Norfolk Southern and officials have yet to respond to the new lawsuit or separate federal claims filed against the EPA and CDC.
Previously, the EPA defended its role in the burning of railcars, saying they were only on the site to provide information about the potential consequences and measure the resulting toxic release of chemicals.
[CRAIG NIGRELLI]
VICE PRESIDENT J-D VANCE ALONG WITH THE HEAD OF THE E-P-A ARE VISITING EAST PALESTINE, OHIO, MONDAY. MARKING TWO YEARS SINCE A DISASTROUS TRAIN DERAILMENT.
HIS VISIT COMES ON THE HEELS OF A NEW LAWSUIT CLAIMING FOR THE FIRST TIME PEOPLE DIED AS A RESULT OF THE TRAIN DERAILMENT’S AFTERMATH.
THE NEW SUIT CONTAINS THE FIRST OF SEVEN WRONGFUL DEATH CLAIMS FILED AGAINST NORFOLK SOUTHERN, INCLUDING THE DEATH OF A 1-WEEK OLD INFANT.
IT ALSO ACCUSES THE RAILROAD AND ITS CONTRACTORS OF MISHANDLING CLEANUP EFFORTS WHILE THE E-P-A AND C-D-C SIGNED OFF ON IT AND FAILED TO TELL RESIDENTS ABOUT THE HEALTH RISKS.
OTHER RESIDENTS IN THE LAWSUIT CITE LINGERING HEALTH PROBLEMS AND ARE CONCERNED THEY MAY BECOME MORE SERIOUS OVER TIME.
COURT DOCUMENTS DESCRIBE SOME OF THE LINGERING HEALTH PROBLEMS, HOWEVER, THEY DO NOT INCLUDE DETAILS ABOUT THE DEATHS.
THE COURT FILINGS FOLLOW A FLURRY OF RECENT LAWSUITS FROM INDIVIDUALS AND BUSINESSES ARGUING A 600-MILLION DOLLAR CLASS-ACTON LAWSUIT DOESN’T OFFER ENOUGH MONEY TO COVER FUTURE EXPENSES LINKED TO THE DISASTER OR TO PREVENT ANOTHER DERAILMENT.
ON FEBRUARY 3RD, 2023, DOZENS OF RAILCARS WENT OFF THE TRACKS, INCLUDING SOME CARRYING TOXIC MATERIALS.
FIVE OF THE CARS CONTAINED VINYL CHLORIDE AND OFFICIALS DECIDED TO BURN THE RAILCARS OVER FEARS OF AN EXPLOSION, AS A RESULT, SPEWING TOXIC PLUMES OF SMOKE INTO THE EAST PALESTINE AREA.
A LATER INVESTIGATION REVEALED THE DECISION TO BURN THE CARS WAS UNNECCESSARY AND MISGUIDED.
NORFOLK SOUTHERN AND OFFICIALS HAVE YET TO RESPOND TO THE NEW LAWSUIT AND SEPARATE FEDERAL CLAIMS FILED AGAINST THE E-P-A AND C-D-C.
PREVIOUSLY, THE E-P-A DEFENDED ITS ROLE IN THE BURNING OF RAILCARS, SAYING THEY WERE ONLY ON SITE TO TO PROVIDE INFORMATION ABOUT THE POTENTIAL CONSEQUENCES AND MEASURE THE RESULTING TOXIC RELEASE.
FOR MORE ON THIS STORY– DOWNLOAD THE STRAIGHT ARROW NEWS APP.
Media Landscape
See how news outlets across the political spectrum are covering this story. Learn moreBias Summary
- Suscipit est ultricies dictumst sodales nec eros interdum mollis, odio sit convallis turpis varius ante curabitur.
- Magna rutrum nibh tincidunt volutpat malesuada parturient dis nec nostra blandit habitasse non quisque pellentesque senectus, porta efficitur tellus vulputate ultricies nulla potenti sapien massa sollicitudin lectus class auctor aliquet.
- Sit pharetra bibendum porta tellus integer vulputate rhoncus turpis ut penatibus lorem auctor quam, tempus ligula ultrices lectus orci mollis neque risus justo convallis senectus ipsum.
- Adipiscing sem maximus interdum inceptos leo taciti dictum magnis orci sagittis massa urna molestie senectus id diam at, eu eros tristique magna cras nascetur ultricies semper litora quam tincidunt mollis lorem nam euismod.
- Condimentum viverra cursus iaculis sapien amet nisl sed arcu ex imperdiet, luctus orci facilisi lorem metus quam nisi pulvinar.
Bias Comparison
Bias Distribution
Left
Right
Untracked Bias
Straight to your inbox.
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.