Intelligence failures left Israel exposed to Oct. 7 Hamas attack: Report

Feb 28

Listen

Ryan Robertson Anchor

By Ryan Robertson (Anchor), William Jackson (Producer), Shianne DeLeon (Video Editor)

Israel’s military released a report on its failures leading up to and during the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attack, citing underestimation of Hamas’ capabilities and misjudgment of the group’s intentions. The attack killed 1,200 Israelis and triggered Israel’s military response in Gaza.
The investigation highlights major intelligence failures, including dismissed warnings of a large-scale Hamas attack and a culture of complacency within Israel’s security establishment.
The report’s findings intensify pressure on Prime Minister Netanyahu, with calls for an independent investigation and reforms in intelligence gathering, threat assessment and emergency response protocols.

Full Story

Israel’s military has released its first official summary of an internal investigation into the failures leading up to and during the Hamas attack on Oct. 7, 2023. The report concludes that the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) underestimated Hamas’ capabilities, misjudged its intentions and ultimately failed to protect Israeli civilians.

Bias Distribution Powered by Ground News™

According to the investigation, Hamas militants stormed the border, killing about 1,200 people and taking 251 hostages, based on Israeli government tallies. The attack triggered Israel’s military response in Gaza, where at least 48,365 people have been killed, according to the Hamas-run Health Ministry.

Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.

Point phone camera here

How did Israeli intelligence misjudge the threat?

The report highlights major intelligence failures. Israeli military analysts incorrectly assessed that Hamas was neither interested in nor preparing for a large-scale war.

The military assumed that any significant escalation would come with early warning signs. These misjudgments led to a lack of preparedness and a delayed response when the attack occurred.

The investigation found that the IDF had shifted its focus to other threats, particularly Hezbollah in Lebanon, leaving Gaza’s border defenses vulnerable.

Intelligence reports from 2018 onward suggested that Hamas was developing an operational plan for a large-scale attack, but these assessments were either dismissed or never escalated to senior military leadership.

What security failures did the report identify?

The investigation points to a broader culture of complacency within Israel’s security establishment. The military relied heavily on surveillance and physical barriers, while failing to reinforce ground forces along the border.

When Hamas launched its assault, the Gaza Division was quickly overrun, forcing Israeli forces to scramble to regain control.

Israeli troops took hours to respond and days to fully clear the border areas of attackers. The report also notes confusion within the chain of command, which contributed to delays in military mobilization.

How has the report affected Netanyahu and the military?

The findings have intensified political pressure on Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who has so far resisted calls for an independent investigation. Netanyahu has stated that any national inquiry should take place only after the war concludes. His critics argue that accountability should come sooner, given the scale of the security failure.

Military leaders, including the outgoing IDF chief of staff, have called for an independent probe to examine both military and government decisions leading up to the attack. The report also recommends reforms in intelligence gathering, threat assessment and emergency response protocols.

What are the ongoing consequences of the attack?

As of now, Israel and Hamas are in a tenuous ceasefire, though Israeli officials still vow to dismantle Hamas. However, the conflict has led to a worsening humanitarian crisis, with most of Gaza’s 2.3 million residents displaced and essential infrastructure severely damaged.

Humanitarian organizations warn that conditions are deteriorating as ceasefire negotiations continue to be strained.

Tags: Benjamin Netanyahu, Gaza, Hamas, Israel, Israel Defense Forces, Palestine

[Ryan Robertson]

ISRAEL’S MILITARY RELEASED ITS FIRST OFFICIAL SUMMARY OF AN INTERNAL INVESTIGATION INTO ITS FAILURES DURING THE OCTOBER 7, 2023, HAMAS ATTACK.

THE INVESTIGATION FINDS THE ISRAEL DEFENSE FORCES UNDERESTIMATED HAMAS’S CAPABILITIES, MISJUDGED ITS INTENTIONS AND ULTIMATELY FAILED TO PROTECT ISRAELI CIVILIANS.

THE 19-PAGE REPORT COVERS MUCH OF WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN—HAMAS MILITANTS STORMED THE BORDER, KILLING 1,200 PEOPLE AND TAKING 251 HOSTAGES, WHICH ULTIMATELY TRIGGERED ISRAEL’S ONGOING MILITARY ACTION IN GAZA.

THE INVESTIGATION OUTLINES HOW ISRAELI INTELLIGENCE MISTAKENLY ASSESSED HAMAS AS UNINTERESTED IN LARGE-SCALE WAR, BELIEVING ANY ATTACK WOULD COME WITH EARLY WARNING SIGNS. BECAUSE OF THIS FALSE BELIEF, THE MILITARY SHIFTED ITS FOCUS TO OTHER THREATS, SUCH AS HEZBOLLAH IN LEBANON, LEAVING ITS SOUTHERN DEFENSES VULNERABLE.

WARNINGS ABOUT HAMAS’S PREPARATIONS WERE EITHER DISMISSED OR NEVER ESCALATED TO SENIOR DECISION-MAKERS.

THE REPORT HIGHLIGHTS A CULTURE OF COMPLACENCY WITHIN ISRAEL’S SECURITY ESTABLISHMENT, POINTING TO A FAILURE TO CHALLENGE LONG-STANDING ASSUMPTIONS ABOUT HAMAS’S STRATEGY. THE MILITARY RELIED HEAVILY ON BARRIERS AND SURVEILLANCE BUT DID NOT REINFORCE GROUND FORCES AT THE BORDER. WHEN THE ATTACK BEGAN, THE GAZA DIVISION WAS QUICKLY OVERRUN. ISRAELI FORCES TOOK HOURS TO RESPOND AND DAYS TO FULLY REGAIN CONTROL OF BORDER AREAS.

THE FINDINGS ARE PUTTING PRESSURE ON PRIME MINISTER BENJAMIN NETANYAHU, WHO INSISTS AN INQUIRY SHOULD WAIT UNTIL THE WAR ENDS. MEANWHILE, MILITARY LEADERS, INCLUDING THE OUTGOING IDF CHIEF OF STAFF, ARE CALLING FOR AN INDEPENDENT INVESTIGATION. CRITICS ACCUSE THE PRIME MINISTER OF INTENTIONALLY PROLONGING THE WAR TO AVOID BEING HELD ACCOUNTABLE.

SOME ISRAELI FORCES ARE STILL OPERATING IN GAZA, TRYING TO FULLY DISMANTLE HAMAS. AT THE SAME TIME, HUMANITARIAN AGENCIES WARN CONDITIONS FOR GAZA’S DISPLACED POPULATION ARE WORSENING AS CEASEFIRE NEGOTIATIONS CONTINUE. THE HAMAS-RUN GAZA HEALTH MINISTRY REPORTS AT LEAST 48,365 DEATHS SINCE THE WAR BEGAN.

FOR MORE OF OUR UNBIASED, STRAIGHT FACT REPORTING – DOWNLOAD THE STRAIGHT ARROW NEWS APP TODAY, OR LOG ON TO SAN.COM.