When women go to the hospital to give birth, most are given medicine to ease the pain of labor. However, an investigation found these drugs prescribed by doctors are the same ones alerting child welfare authorities to their hospital rooms.
Media Landscape
See how news outlets across the political spectrum are covering this story. Learn more
Left 50%
Center 25%
Right 25%
Bias Distribution Powered by Ground News™
The Marshall Project and Reveal News found morphine, fentanyl and other routine narcotics used during birth are putting some moms in custody disputes.
Once a mother and their newborn test positive for drugs, hospital staff report the results to authorities.
Point phone camera here
A New York mother shared her experience with Reveal News. She said she temporarily lost custody of her kids due to a positive drug test, even with no prior history of abuse. She said doctors prescribed her fentanyl during childbirth.
Drug testing of pregnant women grew in popularity during the opioids epidemic in the 1980s. The Marshall Project said the surveillance of women has only continued once Roe v. Wade was overturned.
Doctors typically use cost-effective urine samples to test for narcotics in new mothers. However, The Marshall Project said those tests don’t give a clear picture of when the drugs are used.
The investigation said there aren’t protections in place for mothers who find themselves in these situations. Many hospitals don’t have doctors to double-check the results and provide a more extensive look into the patients’ toxicology.
The investigation also noted social workers assigned to cases aren’t equipped to know what medication was administered to the patient during labor.
According to a 2022 study, researchers found almost 91% of women given fentanyl in an epidural during childbirth will test positive for the drug following the birth. Researchers said doctors should caution their assumptions surrounding a patient’s drug use based on their findings.
Another study reported moms can pass medications onto their babies so often it doesn’t immediately prove they’re abusing drugs.
Mandatory reporting laws in the U.S. protect doctors and nurses for making these reports, regardless if they’re accurate.
More than two dozen states require hospitals to contact child welfare to any positive tests. The investigation said data showed at least 35,000 babies were reported in 2022 for substance exposure.
Earlier this year, the largest healthcare provider in Massachusetts changed their original approach on the issue. Its new policy won’t report mothers just because a newborn is exposed to drugs but rather on gathered evidence that proves abuse.
Get up to speed on the stories leading the day every weekday morning. Sign up for the newsletter today!
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.
New Mexico, Washington and Colorado are among the few states with revised laws that stop social workers from taking infants away from their mothers without any signs of abuse or neglect.
[Karah Rucker]
WHEN WOMEN GO TO THE HOSPITAL TO GIVE BIRTH…THEY’RE GIVEN MEDICINE TO EASE THE PAIN OF LABOR.
AN INVESTIGATION FINDS THESE DRUGS PRESCRIBED BY DOCTORS ARE THE **SAME ONES BRINGING CHILD WELFARE AUTHORITIES TO THEIR HOSPITAL ROOMS.
THE MARSHALL PROJECT AND REVEAL FOUND MORPHINE, FENTANYL AND OTHER ROUTINE NARCOTICS USED DURING BIRTH ARE PUTTING SOME MOMS INTO CUSTODY DISPUTES.
ONCE A MOTHER AND THEIR NEWBORN TEST POSITIVE, HOSPITAL STAFF REPORT THE RESULTS TO OFFICIALS.
A FIRSTHAND ACCOUNT FROM A NEW YORK MOTHER SAYS SHE TEMPORAILY LOST CUSTODY OF HER KIDS DUE TO A POSITIVE DRUG TEST EVEN WITH NO PREVIOUS HISTORY OF ABUSE. SHE TELLS THE NEWS ORGANIZATION IT WAS DOCTORS WHO PRESCRIBED THE FENTANYL.
DRUG TESTING GREW IN POPULARITY DURING THE OPIOID EPIDEMIC AND ACCORDING TO THE MARSHALL PROJECT SURVEILLANCE OF PREGNANT WOMEN HAS ONLY CONTINUED ONCE ROE V WADE WAS OVERTURNED.
RESEARCHERS SAID A 2022 STUDY BY MASSACHUSETTS GENERAL HOSPITAL SHOWS ALMOST 91 PERCENT OF WOMEN GIVEN FENTANYL IN AN EPIDURAL WILL TEST POSITIVE FOR THE DRUG AFTER THE BIRTH… AND BASED ON THEIR FINDINGS IT SHOULD BRING CAUTION TO DOCTORS ABOUT ASSUMING A PATIENTS DRUG USE.
OTHER STUDIES HAVE SHOWN MOMS CAN PASS MEDICATIONS ONTO THEIR BABIES SO OFTEN TIMES IT DOESN’T IMMEDIATELY PROVE THEY ARE ABUSING DRUGS.
THE COMMON TEST TAKES A SAMPLE OF A WOMAN’S URINE…ALTHOUGH COST EFFECTIVE, THE MARSHALL PROJECT SAID IT DOESN’T GIVE A CLEAR PICTURE OF WHEN THE DRUG WAS USED.
THE INVESTIGATION SAID PROTECTIONS AREN’T PUT IN PLACE FOR THE MOTHERS IN THESE SITUATIONS–MANY HOSPITALS DON’T DOUBLE CHECK THE RESULTS AND SOCIAL WORKERS AREN’T EQUIPPED TO KNOW WHAT MEDICATION WAS ADMINISTERED DURING LABOR.
FALSE REPORTS PROMPTED A NEW ENGLAND OBGYN TO CHANGE HIS HOSPITAL’S POLICIES. HE SAID “The hospitals are at fault. The clinicians are at fault. Our policies are at fault.”
EARLIER THIS YEAR MASSACHUSSETT’S LARGEST HEALTH CARE PROVIDER CHANGED THEIR APPROACH…THE NEW POLICY WON’T REPORT MOTHERS JUST BECAUSE A NEWBORN IS BORN EXPOSED TO DRUGS BUT RATHER ON GATHERED EVIDENCE THAT PROVES ABUSE.
NEW MEXICO, WASHINGTON, AND COLORADO ARE AMONG THE STATES WITH REVISED LAWS THAT STOP SOCIAL WORKERS FROM TAKING AWAY INFANTS THAT SHOW NO SIGNS OF ABUSE OR NEGLECT.
MANDATORY REPORTING LAWS IN THE U-S PROTECT DOCTORS AND NURSES FOR MAKING THESE REPORTS REGARDLESS IF THEY AREN’T ACCURATE.
27 STATES REQUIRE HOSPITALS TO CONTACT CHILD WELFARE TO POSITIVE TESTS. AT LEAST 35 THOUSAND BABIES WERE REPORTED IN 2022 FOR SUBSTANCE EXPOSURE.
FOR STRAIGHT ARROW NEWS, I’M KARAH RUCKER.
Media Landscape
See how news outlets across the political spectrum are covering this story. Learn more
Left 50%
Center 25%
Right 25%
Bias Summary
- Varius fames dui eros bibendum posuere lobortis, gravida efficitur penatibus justo class lorem himenaeos, ex tellus nec sodales tincidunt.
- Ipsum montes lacus natoque aptent erat ultricies risus fringilla volutpat est inceptos, lacinia adipiscing elit auctor accumsan dui suscipit tristique sit egestas.
- Quam rutrum turpis volutpat diam sagittis a pellentesque cras dui, sociosqu commodo iaculis consectetur himenaeos consequat ultrices dignissim fermentum, quisque aliquam euismod ornare magna est dapibus dolor.
Bias Comparison
The Left
ante morbi dictumst porttitor sapien leo molestie at diam, quisque feugiat phasellus potenti sagittis torquent vitae.
The Center
at gravida accumsan lobortis varius quam quis nascetur posuere primis odio efficitur amet velit, cras proin senectus praesent facilisis class aptent tellus mi ex turpis.
The Right
nisi non semper maximus vel donec posuere volutpat purus vehicula dis porta, quis vitae phasellus consectetur amet convallis vulputate mauris condimentum cursus.
Report an issue with this comparison
Bias Distribution
11 other sources covering this story
Total News Sources
11
Leaning Left
4
Center
2
Leaning Right
2
Last Updated
4 months ago
Bias Distribution Powered by Ground News™
Straight to your inbox.
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.
