Skip to main content
Politics

Biden, Trump reignite debate over ‘undocumented’ vs. ‘illegal’ immigrants


There is renewed controversy over using the term “illegal immigrant” after President Joe Biden apologized for calling a murder suspect an “illegal.” Former President Donald Trump doubled down in a campaign speech over the weekend of March 9 that Biden should apologize for apologizing over the terminology.

Biden was pressed by Republicans to mention the death of Laken Riley during his State of the Union Address. Riley was a college student murdered in Georgia, and the suspect arrested in her case was in the U.S. illegally.

QR code for SAN app download

Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.

Point phone camera here

When Biden referred to the alleged murderer as “an illegal,” he received backlash from fellow Democrats. On March 9, Biden told MSNBC he “regretted” the word choice.

“I shouldn’t have used illegal, it’s undocumented,” Biden said. “I’m not going to treat any of these people with disrespect.”

While on the campaign trail in Georgia, Trump reacted to Biden’s comments.

“Joe Biden went on television and apologized for calling Laken’s murderer an illegal,” Trump said. “He didn’t want to call him an illegal, so he apologized. He was illegal alien, he was an illegal immigrant, he was an illegal migrant.”

The terms “undocumented migrant” and “illegal migrant” have been heavily politicized. According to AllSides, a media watchdog group which rates news outlets’ biases, Democrats more often use “undocumented persons,” whereas Republicans more often use “illegal immigrants.”

The same goes for how the media refers to this group of people, according to AllSides. Left-leaning news outlets largely refer to “undocumented migrants” while right-leaning news outlets largely refer to “illegal immigrants” in their immigration coverage.

Journalists typically write in AP style. The “AP Stylebook” sets ethical standards across the board in this industry, however, The Associated Press has a left-leaning bias, according to AllSides.

While it used to be acceptable to interchange illegal immigrant and undocumented person, in 2013, AP updated its rulebook.

“Except in direct quotes essential to the story, use ‘illegal’ only to refer to an action, not a person: illegal immigration, but not illegal immigrant.”

News anchors, reporters and media outlets largely use the term “undocumented immigrants” to abide by AP style. However, AllSides has found there are flaws in both terms.

AllSides said the term undocumented immigrant “is overly vague. It doesn’t clearly convey the illegal nature of the act in question.”

According to AllSides, the term illegal immigrant is “technically imprecise because individuals themselves cannot be ‘illegal,’ though their actions may be.”

AllSides said the terms mean the same thing and the definition of both is likely clear to any audience. The term used to describe people who are in the country illegally will vary depending on an individuals political preferences and news outlets of choice.

Tags: , , , , ,

[KARAH RUCKER]

THERE IS RENEWED CONTROVERSY OVER USING THE TERM “ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT” VERSUS “UNDOCUMENTED PERSON” AFTER BIDEN APOLOGIZED FOR CALLING A MURDER SUSPECT AN “ILLEGAL” AND TRUMP DOUBLING DOWN THAT BIDEN SHOULD APOLOGIZE FOR APOLOGIZING.

THIS GIVES US AN OPPORTUNITY TO EXPLAIN THE TERMINOLOGY –

HOW IT’S USED BY THE MEDIA –

AND ETHICAL CONCERNS WITH BOTH TERMS.

BUT FIRST – HOW THE CONVERSATION WAS BROUGHT UP.

DURING BIDEN’S STATE OF THE UNION ADDRESS LAST WEEK – BIDEN WAS PRESSED BY REPUBLICANS TO MENTION THE DEATH OF “LAKEN RILEY” –

A COLLEGE STUDENT MURDERED IN GEORGIA.

THE SUSPECT IN HER CASE? WAS IN THE COUNTRY ILLEGALLY.

[BIDEN]

“Laken Riley, an innocent young woman who was killed by an illegal.

“To her parents, I say my heart goes out to them having lost children myself.”

[KARAH RUCKER]

IT WAS THE WORD “ILLEGAL” THAT WOULDN’T SIT WELL WITH FELLOW DEMOCRATS.

AND OVER THE WEEKEND – PRESIDENT BIDEN TOLD MSNBC HE “REGRETTED” THE WORD CHOICE.

[BIDEN]

“You used the word illegal…Undocumented, undocumented person, I should’ve said undocumented..I’m not going to treat any of these people with disrespect.”

[KARAH RUCKER]

WHILE ON THE CAMPAIGN TRAIL IN GEORGIA THIS WEEKEND –

TRUMP REACTED TO BIDEN’S COMMENTS.

[TRUMP]

“Joe Biden went on television and apologized for calling Laken’s murderer an illegal. He didn’t want to call him an illegal, so he apologized.”

“He was illegal alien, he was an illegal immigrant, he was illegal migrant.”

[KARAH RUCKER]

THE TERMS HAVE BEEN HEAVILY POLITICIZED.

DEMOCRATS MORE OFTEN USE “UNDOCUMENTED PERSONS”

WHEREAS REPUBLICANS MORE OFTEN USE “ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS”.

THE SAME GOES FOR HOW THE MEDIA REFERS TO THIS GROUP OF PEOPLE.

HERE ARE A FEW EXAMPLES FROM LEFT-LEANING NEWS OUTLETS.

IN THEIR VARIOUS NEWS COVERAGE –

CBS, ABC, AND MSNBC REFER TO “UNDOCUMENTED IMMIGRANTS.”

THEN YOU LOOK AT RIGHT-LEANING MEDIA OUTLETS AND THEIR NEWS COVERAGE ON VARIOUS IMMIGRANT STORIES.

“ILLEGALS” “ILLEGAL MEXICAN MIGRANT” AND “ILLEGAL ALIENS” ARE THE TERMS USED IN THEIR HEADLINES.

JOURNALISTS TYPICALLY WRITE IN AP-STYLE.

THERE IS AN “AP STYLE GUIDEBOOK” THAT SORT OF SETS “ETHICAL STANDARDS” ACROSS THE BOARD IN THIS INDUSTRY –

EVEN THOUGH AP DOES HAVE A LEFT-LEANING BIAS.

WHILE IT USED TO BE ACCEPTABLE TO INTERCHANGE ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT AND UNDOCUMENTED PERSON –

IN 2013 – AP UPDATED ITS RULEBOOK.

“Except in direct quotes essential to the story, use “illegal” only to refer to an action, not a person: illegal immigration, but not illegal immigrant.”

THAT’S WHY YOU LARGELY ONLY HEAR NEWS ANCHORS AND REPORTERS USE THE TERM “UNDOCUMENTED IMMIGRANTS.” TO ABIDE BY AP STYLE.

HOWEVER –

A MEDIA WATCHDOG GROUP – “ALL-SIDES” – WHICH RATES NEWS OUTLETS’ BIASES –

HAS FOUND THERE ARE FLAWS IN BOTH TERMS.

THEY SAY THE TERM UNDOCUMENTED IMMIGRANT “is overly vague. It doesn’t clearly convey the illegal nature of the act in question.”

AND THE TERM “ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT” is “technically imprecise because individuals themselves cannot be “illegal,” though their actions may be.”

ALL-SIDES SAYS THE TERMS MEAN THE SAME THING.

AND THE DEFINITION OF BOTH IS LIKELY CLEAR TO ANY AUDIENCE.

BUT DEPENDING ON POLITICAL PREFERENCES AND WHERE YOU GET YOUR NEWS –

THE TERM USED WILL VARY.

THIS IS A SENSITIVE ISSUE –

BUT NOT SOMETHING WE’RE GOING TO SHY AWAY FROM.

WE WANT TO OFFER YOU A DIFFERENT EXPERIENCE IN THE WAY YOU CONSUME NEWS.

THAT’S WHY ALL-SIDES – HAS GIVEN US A CENTER RATING – MEANING OUR NEWS DOESN’T HAVE A LEFT OR RIGHT LEANING BIAS TO IT.

WE THINK IT’S IMPORTANT TO KEEP THIS RATING IN ORDER TO BUILD TRUST WITH YOU.

ESPECIALLY IN AN ELECTION YEAR –

WHEN ACCURATE AND UNBIASED INFORMATION – IS WHAT YOU – OUR VIEWER – DESERVES.